Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

zoran

macrumors 601
Original poster
Jun 30, 2005
4,881
136
Has anyone tried using it as a TV? Is it better or worse than the plasma or LCD tv displays that are around?
 
zoran said:
Has anyone tried using it as a TV? Is it better or worse than the plasma or LCD tv displays that are around?

well lets put it this way, i believe the highest resolution TVs around are about 1080 I think (not sure)

so the 30" ACD would have a much higher resolution than the output from the cable tv.

however, i have standard def TV on my 20" monitor and it looks fine fullscreen. So I guess it may be fine for some and not for others.

Also you would I believe have to use eyeTV for it if it is connected through a computer, or something comporable.
 
i wouldn't, standard tv on it would be awful 640x480 to 2560x1600 which it would have make it 13 times bigger and pixelate the hell out of it. for dvd about the same. and high def would look ok, if you could get an uncompressed feed into it.

Plasma's and lcd-tv are designed to show those lower resolution images, and have special processors and filters to make it look good. Sure you could do it, but i woudn't recomend it, in fact recomend not to.
 
Rokem said:
i wouldn't, standard tv on it would be awful 640x480 to 2560x1600 which it would have make it 13 times bigger and pixelate the hell out of it. for dvd about the same. and high def would look ok, if you could get an uncompressed feed into it.

Plasma's and lcd-tv are designed to show those lower resolution images, and have special processors and filters to make it look good. Sure you could do it, but i woudn't recomend it, in fact recomend not to.

So, I don't have a TV and don't really want one but I watch about 3 DVDs from Netflix a week on my 12" PB. I've also begun scanning the family photo albums and would like to get a bigger monitor. I was thinking of a 19" LCD and was wondering if I could buy a cheap DVD player and hook it up directly to the monitor via DVI, therefore saving wear and tear on my PB. Would this work, would it look ok?
 
A computer monitor works well for viewing TV and DVDs, as long as you're not too close to it. "Too close" depends on the size of the monitor and the resolution of what you're watching. People tend to sit closer to monitors than TVs and so notice artifacts more easily. Sit back a bit, and it'll look fine.
 
But sitting back so that all seems fine is what can happen with a plasma or lcd telly, well sort of and after all thats subjective. Hasnt anyone tested the 30'' ACD with tv and tell us the results compared to a telly?
 
while i have never done this it wont look as good as tv becuase a tv doesnt expect preprocessed video, while a comp. monitor expects a preprocessed video and has minimum video processing abilities.

as someone said erlier Distance=Good.
 
is there any option other than eyetv to get tv on your computer?

seems like it it wouldnt be that hard to figure a way.......

or maybe im just stupid lol


i mean is there a way to get a box that has a cable input and outputs via dvi or vga for video and a minijack port for audio? granted no computer interface or anything but seems like its doable


anyone else agree?
 
dukebound85 said:
is there any option other than eyetv to get tv on your computer?

seems like it it wouldnt be that hard to figure a way.......

or maybe im just stupid lol


i mean is there a way to get a box that has a cable input and outputs via dvi or vga for video and a minijack port for audio? granted no computer interface or anything but seems like its doable


anyone else agree?

while their is a way to do this its normally used by pros with a pro price tag on it like 2499. My cable box has a dvi out on it and something to convert rca plug audio are really cheap. I might try this with my 15" dell lcd. ohh yah you can start being jellous... :cool:
 
Rokem said:
while their is a way to do this its normally used by pros with a pro price tag on it like 2499. My cable box has a dvi out on it and something to convert rca plug audio are really cheap. I might try this with my 15" dell lcd. ohh yah you can start being jellous... :cool:


totally let me know if it works
 
Yes, but...

dukebound85 said:
i mean is there a way to get a box that has a cable input and outputs via dvi or vga for video and a minijack port for audio? granted no computer interface or anything but seems like its doable


I know one...you can plug coaxial into one end and then vga or DVI into another.

Yeah...it's called EYETV.
 
appleretailguy said:
I know one...you can plug coaxial into one end and then vga or DVI into another.

Yeah...it's called EYETV.


well if you looked at my first post, i asked if there was a way besides eyetv..... doesnt seem like too hard of a technology to duplicate
 
Yeah...

dukebound85 said:
well if you looked at my first post, i asked if there was a way besides eyetv..... doesnt seem like too hard of a technology to duplicate

You obviously missed the sarcasm in my post.

If it doesn't seem like it's too hard to duplicate, why do you think you haven't received any other options?
 
appleretailguy said:
You obviously missed the sarcasm in my post.

If it doesn't seem like it's too hard to duplicate, why do you think you haven't received any other options?

sorry sometimes sarcasm is hard to pick up in writing lol

im just saying its probably not the hardest thing to do compared to making crt's cars and anything else we have. .sure may not be easy but im suprised not more comapnies have done this
 
Yeah...

You're right...I have wanted a device like this for a while--let's call it a converter for now--but have balked at paying the price of a new TV JUST for the converter.
 
Rokem said:
i didn't realize that there were different types of dvi cables and the one on my monitor has 4 extra pins on it that makes it not fit. :mad:

Yes...there are several different types of DVI connectors. The Apple Cinema Displays use DVI-I connectors...single-link for the 20" and 23" and dual-link for the 30".
 
Hm I'm thinking about doing this too... but would probably be cheaper to sell the ACD and buy a nice LCD TV instead...
 
It depends on how much you want to spend. Check out the Viewsonic HD12 (link) I don't have the HD12, so I can't comment on performance. It would probably work, but at $400, you might want to consider a TV if you plan to do a lot of TV watching.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.