Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

SpecG

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 6, 2014
10
4
Using an external monitor I'm seeing less than 4 hours on the 15 inch, 455, 2.7, regardless of activity. Even just one tab open on Safari results in this. All indexing has been completed. Seems Apple's claimed 10 hours only applies to integrated 530 graphics. If the dGPU kicks in, expect that to drop by 50 - 75%.
 
That seems to be in line with what I would personally expect. I think most people have access to their power adapter when they plug in their external monitor, so this shouldn't be a huge issue, no?
 
This has always been the case with an external monitor connected. What's the issue?
 
Who the hell is connected to an external monitor while not being plugged in charging though?
 
If you are using an external monitor, you can also use the charger. I don't see a problem.
 
Not an issue necessarily, just a datapoint. I was seeing 7 hours plus when attached to an external monitor with a 12 inch MacBook.
 
Not an issue necessarily, just a datapoint. I was seeing 7 hours plus when attached to an external monitor with a 12 inch MacBook.
Massive difference in gpu power consumption hence the difference
 
If the dGPU kicks in, expect that to drop by 50 - 75%.

No different on my 2015 model. Integrated graphics and light work = respectable battery life (6-8+ hours)

AdobeCC Programs/ FCPX / Ableton / Logic / Any big program that uses a lot of resources and dGPU = 2-4 hours
 
Massive difference in gpu power consumption hence the difference

Understood. Being used to the one port scenario I was surprised to see a meagre 1440p monitor bring down the battery life so much.

Guess dGPU is anavoidable with anything attached. Leaves you wondering how the MacBook m5 does it without an issue though...
 
Understood. Being used to the one port scenario I was surprised to see a meagre 1440p monitor bring down the battery life so much.

Power management plays a large role. I would imagine that the dGPU is configured with performance scenarios in mind, so if it kicks in, the power draw will be substantial. Besides, the VRAM requires a lot of power to run. And the reason why the dGPU kicks in with external monitors is because external video output is wired through the dGPU (AFAIK the iGPU can't output external video directly on these MBPs).

The MacBook behaves differently because it doesn't really care about how many monitors are being connected. The iGPU just needs to draw a bit more stuff, usually its neglectable. Most of the time, only a small fraction of the screen needs to be redrawn and modern OSes are fairly good at optimising this procedure.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.