6 weeks in: A twist on ye ol' iOS 7 icon poll

[cleo1]

Here's the game:
'Yea' or 'nay', just like with your grandaddy's iOS 7 icon poll, but this time, if you vote 'nay' you must back up your convictions and include an alternative icon set you deem superior. Go!

 

[Shrink]

Another absolutely essential iOS 7 icon thread.

Completely original concept here, though...so certainly not redundant or superfluous...

 

[AngerDanger]

Another absolutely essential iOS 7 icon thread.

Completely original concept here, though...so certainly not redundant or superfluous...

And another one of these comments. Nobody saw this coming.

I'd be interested in such a poll, but anticipating a firestorm of criticism for starting "another icon thread," I think I'll pass.

 

[cleo1]

Noise-to-signal ratio rather high on this thread.

 

[dejo]

Where's the poll?

 

[cleo1]

Where's the poll?

It's written-answer.

 

[Gogurt48]

I prefer this icon set to Apple's:

 

[Rogifan]

Another absolutely essential iOS 7 icon thread.

Completely original concept here, though...so certainly not redundant or superfluous...

Wasteland perhaps?

 

[Shrink]

And another one of these comments. Nobody saw this coming.

You're right!

But is it unfair to point out the magnitude of the redundancy?

Yes, I know pointing it out is redundant...catch 22.

Wasteland perhaps?

Works for me!

 

[cleo1]

You're right!

But is it unfair to point out the magnitude of the redundancy?

Yes, I know pointing it out is redundant...catch 22.




Works for me!

The redundancy is largely due to threads full of comments on how stupid the thread is rather than actual contributions. It is only because of this low wheat-to-chaff ratio that these polls need to be conducted and re-conducted. It is an important topic and if everyone would answer seriously, we could be done with it. That being said, I vote to keep the icons exactly as is.

 

[Shrink]

The redundancy is largely due to threads full of comments on how stupid the thread is rather than actual contributions. It is only because of this low wheat-to-chaff ratio that these polls need to be conducted and re-conducted. It is an important topic and if everyone would answer seriously, we could be done with it. That being said, I vote to keep the icons exactly as is.

Your point is taken, though I might not agree about the importance of the topic (over and over) as it will make absolutely no difference at all in the ultimate outcome in iOS 7.

 

[KenAFSPC]

Nay.

I particularly like the top set with the very subtle 3D effect.