Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

pullman

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Feb 11, 2008
880
155
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I just read this "review", more of an opinion piece really, and thought it really doesn't describe accurately the user experience of the iPhone X. Has anyone else seen it?

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jeanba...hone-x-is-the-worst-iphone-ever/#1af2ede57dde

I've only had mine a few days but I am overall very pleased with how Apple has implemented the gestures. I think Face ID is great and find it magical that it works in complete darkness.

There is, as Jean Babtiste Su notes, an extra step to have to swipe up to come to the home screen but I have a feeling that will be made optional in a later iOS update; some might like that, others might prefer to get to the home screen directly.

However, I certainly don't relate at all to Babtiste Su's view that it takes 2-3 seconds for Face ID to work. On my phone it is as fast as Touch ID, if not actually faster. Touch ID, on the other hand, would repeatedly fail if I my fingers were either too cold, too warm or a bit wet. Face ID has never failed to recognise me.

I also don't understand the problem he has with swiping up; that has never failed on mine but then again I have no notifications on the home screen (which he says causes the delay) because I find them distracting.

There is also a comment in the piece about the tap to wake function which he writes "hopefully" will work. I don't know if he has actually tried it but tap to wake is very effective. And it is not necessary to "fly" one's head over the device; mine unlooks at a distance of about 40cm and a 45 degree angle. That's pretty amazing tech at work, imho, and a very userfriendly implementation of the function.

Babtiste Su has a point about how Control Center is invoked; that is less than ideal on a taller phone. What I do is use the "reachability" function (activated in apps too) and then swipe down at right on the middle of the screen. Works extremely well.

What also works well I find is the swipe up and hold for the app switcher. I was initially quite reluctant to this function but I quickly became used to it. Contrary to what he writes, it has never failed on my phone.
 
The best part is that he claims Apple will bring back Touch ID with the release of the next generation iPhone X. :rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: willmtaylor
Forbes is terrible... When I am doing research on something and I see a Forbes article I move along to the next without ever clicking their link..

When I do click their links, I'm reminded that they don't work with my ad blockers. And I don't work with their ads. So it's a mutual decision to avoid them. :)
 
I don't know if it's the worst iPhone ever but I do know it's the only one I've had no interest at all in buying.

I'm sure it's going to lead to better phones in the future but for me personally it feels more like a way for Apple to bridge the old and new worlds than a true leap forwards and I'm happy to wait until all the compromises have been removed
 
I've only had mine a few days but I am overall very pleased with how Apple has implemented the gestures.

Personally love the gestures. It was one of the main reasons I wanted the X.

I think Face ID is great and find it magical that it works in complete darkness.
I have a love/hate relationship currently with FaceID. I look very forward to Gen 2.

There is, as Jean Babtiste Su notes, an extra step to have to swipe up to come to the home screen but I have a feeling that will be made optional in a later iOS update; some might like that, others might prefer to get to the home screen directly.
I like the swipe up as it gives me time to view my notifications. Honestly, the swipe up is really a non issue.

However, I certainly don't relate at all to Babtiste Su's view that it takes 2-3 seconds for Face ID to work.
I personally have experienced a lag with FaceID on numerous occasions. But I also faced lag with touchID at times.

Face ID has never failed to recognise me.
Hard to believe, but if so, you are quite lucky :)

I also don't understand the problem he has with swiping up; that has never failed on mine
Mine either.

There is also a comment in the piece about the tap to wake function which he writes "hopefully" will work.
Love tap to wake. On my X I have the Raise to wake feature off and use Tap to wake extensively. I so wish I had this on my iPad Pro.

Babtiste Su has a point about how Control Center is invoked; that is less than ideal on a taller phone. What I do is use the "reachability" function (activated in apps too) and then swipe down at right on the middle of the screen. Works extremely well.
I agree with Baptisate on this point. Horrible implementation by apple of control center. This will most likely change in the future.
 
I don’t care if they think it’s terrible

Genuinely doesn’t affect me in any capacity and I welcome a diversity of opinion even though it feels like clickbait

But if they were gonna be bold, why not at launch?

At least verge posed the question “what if 8plus is better than X”

Which I thought was cool

I love my jailbroken X. I feel on That new level
 
Meh implementation of gesture (esp the control center one), not that fast Face ID (noticeable delays on my face. Work, but almost always delay for unknown reason), weird home bar position (esp in landscape, which is a dangerous position when playing certain games), notch (a deal breaker), and on and on.
I don’t say I necessarily agree with Forbes guy’s point, but iPhone X is definitely not the best phone out there. Samesung S9 is better than iPhone X in many ways. Plus it has a headphone jack.

I hope next gen iPhone and iOS 12 could eliminate some silly gestures, reduce the notch (based on rumor), improve Face ID (I can see it’s superiority over Touch ID) and perfect the phone. After that, I might consider upgrading.
 
I will not give Forbes a click. I know that Forbes is a bad spot to look for a review. They did the same when the Apple watch was released.

Avoid that site in the future is my advice for you.
 
Iphone 7 was the worst Iphone and I only say that because it literally was an iphone 6 with a different camera bump.
 
Iphone 7 was the worst Iphone and I only say that because it literally was an iphone 6...
and the iPhone8 is almost the same as the iPhone7

the iphonex is the premium price item so it must be much better

all these phones are defined by the software and are the same. Not the incremental changes in hardware
 
I agree with Baptisate on this point. Horrible implementation by apple of control center. This will most likely change in the future.
Don’t own an X so I can’t comment on everything else but definitely hate how control center is setup on the X.

I plan on getting the plus sized X and it definitely would be annoying having to reach to the top for CC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Raist3001
I find this part hilarious:

2BB4A12A-8664-4537-9003-9A9AB758C447.jpeg

Lol, it took weeks to take the original photo and make it larger?

Forbes is so full of junk from contributors...errr... oops I mean “experts” and “analysts” like this guy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: willmtaylor
That author is entitled to their opinion, and they can use whatever phone they wish - clearly though this is a click bait article

I think, overall, the iPhone X is the best iPhone ever. FaceID isn't for everyone though. I like it, but it's not perfect.
 
Forbes is just a chatterbox when it comes to technology. You will never learn anything that has not already been leaked to another site
Reading Forbes for Apple stories is a waist of time. Instead of reading Forbes go to the bathroom and do something useful!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Magnusson
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.