Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

^_^

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 30, 2016
24
33
Hey guys!

I've been trying to decide on an iPhone 17 color, and I'm torn between blue and black. Since I've wanted to give the original Apple silicone case a chance, I figured I could pair the blue phone with the purple case for a "toy"-like design:

1765766493400.png

Pairing the same case with the black phone would be insanely boring, as you can see:
1765766508004.png


(Both screenshots were taken from this video).

If I knew for sure that I'd keep that case for years, the color choice for the phone would be easy—blue. However, I'm only interested in trying it once, and I don't expect it to age well (I've read reviews). I've never had one of these, though, so I would like to give it a shot.

In case I do end up with a different case sooner or later, I'd probably want to try a red case at some point, and perhaps even a leather case (most likely in brown). I'm not sure how well those colors would look on a blue iPhone, while they would undoubtedly look good on a neutral black phone.

I think making the choice has been so difficult for me because I can't seem to find dedicated base iPhone 17 threads or videos—this one being the exception.

It seems that everyone's only posting Pro and Pro Max pictures, and I get it. This year, with the base phone finally having a "ProMotion" screen, I realized I can finally opt for the base model. Otherwise, I would have gone for the Pro or Pro Max as well. I recognized the 17 was a great phone while watching the unveiling in September, and I wasn't surprised to see that sentiment echoed everywhere afterwards. That's the only reason I'm surprised that there aren't more dedicated accessories posts about it. If you guys do know of any, please do let me know!

In the meantime, I'd appreciate your input, along with a pic of your blue base 17 with a brownish leather case or even a red one (Technically Red by Andar comes to mind).

Thanks a lot!
 
I would definitely go with black. I’m not a big fan of that blue tbh. Also, like you mentioned, the black will go with any case you like while it’ll be a bit tougher with blue
 
I would definitely go with black. I’m not a big fan of that blue tbh. Also, like you mentioned, the black will go with any case you like while it’ll be a bit tougher with blue

it is always a safer bet, but the blue 17 looks more distinctly iPhone 17 where black looks like another iPhone 16. which may not be an issue but.. guess I'm biased coming from a black 16 plus :p
 
it is always a safer bet, but the blue 17 looks more distinctly iPhone 17 where black looks like another iPhone 16. which may not be an issue but.. guess I'm biased coming from a black 16 plus :p
Edit: realized my comment made no sense haha
 
Thanks guys!

I would definitely go with black. I’m not a big fan of that blue tbh. Also, like you mentioned, the black will go with any case you like while it’ll be a bit tougher with blue

While I agree that every case will technically fit the black phone, it doesn't mean that the pairing will look as fun. For example, I'd never get that purple silicone case for the black phone because I find it dull and boring. The blue color makes it pop. I think I'd be able to make a more informed decision if I could find a picture of a blue iPhone 17 with a classic leather case, but I guess no one has bothered posting one of those online. 🤷‍♂️

first looks more fun to my eyes

No doubt! And, as I mentioned, if I knew for a fact that I'd be using that case for years to come, then I'd definitely go with the blue. However, I'm not sure the silicone case will age well, and so I'll most likely have to replace it eventually. That's why I'm having trouble making up my mind. I can't even seem to find posts from users sharing their base iPhone 17 case combos.

it is always a safer bet, but the blue 17 looks more distinctly iPhone 17 where black looks like another iPhone 16. which may not be an issue but.. guess I'm biased coming from a black 16 plus :p

I wouldn't really mind that part, tbh. I'm only concerned about potential pairing with future cases. As I mentioned, it's unfortunate I can't see how classic brown/orange leather cases fit the blue iPhone 17 because I think that will be my go-to if the silicone case fails. A case whose texture only becomes richer and more fun with time is way better than one that gradually degrades.

If I have to work with what I have (that is, the videos I did find), I guess I'll just go with the blue, get the purple case, and hope for the best. 😅
 
  • Like
Reactions: AnthroMatt
ugh... Since only the color around the camera lens is relevant to me, given that I'll be using a phone case at all times, I'm wondering whether the more accurate blue is the one shown indoors around the 4:42 mark in this video, or outdoors at about 7:29.

I really dislike the shade of blue around the camera lens outside, and if that's a more accurate representation of what it looks like, I'll just get the black after all. |:

Thanks!

EDIT: yeah, decided to go for the black given that unsettling revelation 😹 Thanks guys!
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.