Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

tomd25

macrumors member
Original poster
Nov 10, 2009
43
17
My 2017 MacBook developed a few faults about 1 year in: the keyboard started failing (spacebar mainly), one speaker stopped working, and the screen developed yellow/brown “blobs” in the bottom corners which seemed to move around depending on unknown factors.

I took it in to Apple after it got too bad to live with and they replaced the screen and bottom assembly. Now about six months later, the exact same three faults have reappeared (except it’s the J key this time).

Obviously we all know about the keyboard, and I think it’s disgusting that Apple are not forced to replace the evidently totally flawed 2017 one with a newer, more robust version, but actually the screen issue bothers me more - it looks horrible, and seems like a very strange issue which evidently was not solved by whatever they did last time.

Due to these faults occurring twice in such a short space of time (the laptop is just over two years old), I’d like to request a replacement rather than a repair from Apple while I am under AppleCare - I have zero faith this won’t just happen again, it seems like underlying issues either in my laptop or the 2017 design.

Does anyone have any advice on the right things to say/do to get a replacement? I’m in the U.K. so consumer law is an option, I also have just under a year of AppleCare remaining. I’ve spent a pretty decent amount on Apple stuff over the years (£15k or so over the last five years I guess), if that in any way helps argue things.

Needless to say I’m pretty disappointed in the quality of this laptop and hope Apple can make it right!
 
sorry, i don't have any advice on getting a replacement. i would get it repaired by applecare, then sell it with the remaining applecare warranty and buy the new mbp 16" coming out this fall.
 
Advice I received from Apple Support: build a case and a paper trail. Call the Apple Support number and talk to a tech rep there. They will open a case for you and assign you a case number. Tell them what's happened already, what Apple has done and what's happening now. Be calm and professional. If a new problem develops, call back and report that. The idea is that, when you take you machine in again, the case number will be tied to you, and the people in the store will see you've reported it and it will help your case.

I *think* Apple's policy is to replace a machine after three repairs, so you may have to go through this again. However, I'm in the US, and you're not, so your local laws may be different.
 
I agree go through the process three is the lucky number. HP is the same way after three repairs they replacement so yeah bill a case with Apple

Advice I received from Apple Support: build a case and a paper trail. Call the Apple Support number and talk to a tech rep there. They will open a case for you and assign you a case number. Tell them what's happened already, what Apple has done and what's happening now. Be calm and professional. If a new problem develops, call back and report that. The idea is that, when you take you machine in again, the case number will be tied to you, and the people in the store will see you've reported it and it will help your case.

I *think* Apple's policy is to replace a machine after three repairs, so you may have to go through this again. However, I'm in the US, and you're not, so your local laws may be different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ascender
sorry, i don't have any advice on getting a replacement. i would get it repaired by applecare, then sell it with the remaining applecare warranty and buy the new mbp 16" coming out this fall.
When this fall will the 16" arrive stores? Also will there be a 14" to replace the 13"? What about the keyboard on the 16" - which type? Butterfly?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.