AE reception? Ibook & Powerbook (15")...

[netytan]

Hey guys, just reading a few threads and I read a few times that the Ibook has better AP reception that the Powerbook? Whats that about, surly the reception would be the same for the two since they are both using the same hardware (AirPort Extreme)?

Thanks,

Mark.

 

[krimson]

IIRC, it's how the antenna are positioned in the case.

 

[netytan]

Ah, that makes a little sence... Is this a huge problem or is the difference even knowticable?

Mark.

 

[Jovian9]

I've had a G4 iBook and now a 17" Aluminum PowerBook. I've used both with AE and have noticed only a slight difference in reception quality....a little better with the iBook but nothing worth choosing an iBook over the PowerBook.

 

[netytan]

I've had a G4 iBook and now a 17" Aluminum PowerBook. I've used both with AE and have noticed only a slight difference in reception quality....a little better with the iBook but nothing worth choosing an iBook over the PowerBook.

Thats good to know! You would have thought apple would have tested these things though.. i mean car makers spends ages making this kind of refinment it would be nice to see such care with the powerbook. But how could apple put more care in? I mean look at the thing!

One more question. Can you use the AE to talk to another Ibook and or Powerbook, or just to connect to a Wifi network? (Without the Base station). If not how would you suggest getting the two networked?

Mark.

 

[tamara6]

Yes. iBooks and Powerbooks with some flavor of airport can connect to any open wifi network. They can also connect to each other, although transferring large files is really slow if one or both is using airport (not extreme). For large files use ethernet or firewire.

 

[virividox]

the worst reception is from the ti books but the al books are fine

 

[Godfather]

I thought it had to do with the case(material)... not the antenna...

 

[zulgand04]

The metal case in the Al books causes a lil bit of loss in singal compared to the ibooks. But its not that big of a deal. Now the Ti books were so bad due to where there antenna was placed in the ibooks and Al books the antenna is in the screen creating much improved reception.

when i say Al book i mean Powerbook

-Neal

 

[netytan]

Ah, theres a shame but i guess not really too bad. At least they solved the problem with the antena possition in the new Powerbooks. Just a shame that beautiful case is such a bitch!

In any case i'll try the AE to AE with my friend when mine arives though i don't think it'll be a huge problem, and it is then we can always use firewire or ethanet like you recomended . It was more for the possibility of playing games.

Later all,

Mark.