Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

qbiq

macrumors member
Original poster
Jul 22, 2011
48
0
I can't get it to work on 10.8.4 so, is that supposed to work now or is that feature coming when OS X Maverick is released?
 
I can't get it to work on 10.8.4 so, is that supposed to work now or is that feature coming when OS X Maverick is released?

No. AirDrop for iOS uses a proprietary Wi-Fi Direct protocol and AirDrop for Mac OS uses a Wi-Fi Ad Hoc Bonjour connection. They don't connect together.
 
They should have called it something else then, using the same name implies that it works together.
 
They should have called it something else then, using the same name implies that it works together.
This seems obvious...perhaps iOS 7.1 will work with Macs also? Apple can't just call something on Mac and something on iOS the same name if it's never going to work together.
air drop in IOS 7 requires OSX 10.8.5 or higher!
Nope. Got 10.8.5, AirDrop open on my Mac & iPhone 5, bluetooth & wifi on on both devices, nothing.
 
I'm just going by what they said.

And to tell you the truth, I don't think a lot of people even know AirDrop exists on the Mac. Plus a lot of iPhone / iPad users don't even own Macs, so I don't see I being much of a problem.
 
It really would be nice if they added this feature between the mac and iOS. That would make it easier to share items between platforms. We have seen Apple add features of iOS to the Mac in the past, so hopefully this will be added with a future update. I am using Dropbox to do this now.
 
And since it's impossible to create ad-hoc networks on iPhones ... oh wait ...

They can, but doing so on a mobile device is KILLER to the battery and EXTREMELY inefficient compared to Wi-Fi Direct, not to mention if you do so, the chips in the iPhone would boot you off wifi, in order to establish a connection.

Not to mention the file systems on the Mac are completely differently structured, which could easily cause issues.

Besides, other than screenshots, why would you need AirDrop iOS to OS X?
 
They should have called it something else then, using the same name implies that it works together.

That's true. Airdrop on macs only works between macs, vice versa for ios. Many end users are going to confuse this. I would hv to think that apple will add this feature in the future between platforms.
 
They can, but doing so on a mobile device is KILLER to the battery and EXTREMELY inefficient compared to Wi-Fi Direct, not to mention if you do so, the chips in the iPhone would boot you off wifi, in order to establish a connection.

Not to mention the file systems on the Mac are completely differently structured, which could easily cause issues.

Besides, other than screenshots, why would you need AirDrop iOS to OS X?

What? So i can play mino gore with my friend (uses a wifi ad hoc connection), but can't transfer files.

Yeah :D

Last part of your theory must be a joke otherwise i don;t know what to think.
 
What? So i can play mino gore with my friend (uses a wifi ad hoc connection), but can't transfer files.

Yeah :D

Last part of your theory must be a joke otherwise i don;t know what to think.

Local games on the iPhone uses Bluetooth, not Wi-Fi Ad Hoc.
 
Local games on the iPhone uses Bluetooth, not Wi-Fi Ad Hoc.

Screenshot%202013-09-15%2017.26.03.png


Really?

Plenty wifi multiplayer games out there: http://toucharcade.com/category/games/wi-fi-multiplayer/
 
Last edited:

Fair Enough.

Anyways, AirDrop for OS X uses a Bonjour Ad Hoc protocol, which the iPhone doesn't support.

And even still, if my theory is wrong, there are plenty of possible reasons:

-The filesystem structures are incompatible
-Two programs written for different protocols
-iTunes WiFi Sync solves the issue already
-The connectivity wasn't ready by iOS 7 launch/Mavericks

But again, I don't see what you could really do other than transfer screenshots/videos from the phone to the computer, which you can already do wirelessly.
 
Last edited:
Fair Enough.

Anyways, AirDrop for OS X uses a Bonjour Ad Hoc protocol, which the iPhone doesn't support.

And even still, if my theory is wrong, there are plenty of possible reasons:

-The filesystem structures are incompatible
-Two programs written for different protocols
-iTunes WiFi Sync solves the issue already
-The connectivity wasn't ready by iOS 7 launch/Mavericks

But again, I don't see what you could really do other than transfer screenshots/videos from the phone to the computer, which you can already do wirelessly.

iOS supports Bonjour. Wake up.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.