Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
70,780
42,707


Apple's new AirTag introduces a series of small improvements, so how does it compare to the original model from 2021?

AirTag-2-Buyers-Guide-Feature.jpg

The second-generation AirTag arrives five years after the original, bringing improvements to tracking range, speaker output, and internal design while retaining the same outward design and accessory compatibility. At the same time, first-generation AirTags remain available from some retailers at reduced prices, raising the question of whether the newer model is worth choosing over the original, or whether the earlier AirTag still makes sense as a lower-cost option.

The comparison below outlines every difference between the two generations, including Apple-announced feature upgrades and hardware changes identified through teardowns. While both models perform the same core function of tracking items through the Find My network, there are some small differences worth noting:

AirTag (first-generation, 2021)AirTag (second-generation, 2026)
First-generation Ultra Wideband chipSecond-generation Ultra Wideband chip
Shorter Precision Finding rangeUp to 50% farther Precision Finding range
Precision Finding on iPhone onlyPrecision Finding on iPhone and Apple Watch (Series 9 and later and Ultra 2)
Earlier Bluetooth implementationUpgraded Bluetooth with increased range
Bluetooth identifiers rotate at standard intervalsBluetooth identifiers rotate more frequently
Standard speaker volumeUp to 50% louder speaker
Chime note in FChime note in G
Works on earlier supported iOS versionsRequires iOS 26.2.1 or later
Reset without a required wait between battery removalsReset requires battery out for at least five seconds each cycle
11g weight11.8g weight (around 7% heavier)
Back text listing "Assembled in China" and "Designed by Apple"Back text listing IP67, NFC, and Find My
Thicker main PCBThinner main PCB with revised battery connectors, and additional test pads and markings
Smaller speaker coilSlightly larger speaker coil
Speaker magnet more easily removableSpeaker magnet more firmly secured and harder to remove
Wider box with flat printed text and plastic pull tabsRedesigned narrower box with updated artwork, raised UV printed text, and paper pull tabs
Folio-style inner tray holding up to two rows of two AirTagsRedesigned inner tray with simpler design holding up to four AirTags


For buyers choosing between the two AirTag models, the decision depends less on basic tracking and more on how and where an AirTag is typically used. Both generations rely on the same Find My network for long-distance location updates, offer similar battery life, and work with the same accessories, so neither model is considerably better for general item tracking.

The second-generation AirTag is likely to benefit users who frequently rely on Precision Finding rather than approximate location. The extended Ultra Wideband range makes it easier to determine the specific location of items, while the louder speaker improves audibility in noisy spaces or when an AirTag is buried inside a bag or suitcase. Support for Precision Finding on compatible Apple Watch models also makes the newer AirTag more convenient for users who often leave their iPhone behind.

The first-generation AirTag remains a practical option for the overwhelming majority of use cases, such as tracking keys, backpacks, or household items that are usually misplaced within short distances. If available at a meaningful discount, it may offer better value for users who do not need Precision Finding at extended range, do not use an Apple Watch for item location, or simply want basic Find My functionality at the lowest cost.

For existing AirTag owners, there is certainly no pressing need to upgrade. For new buyers, the second-generation AirTag simply offers the most complete feature set and greater flexibility going forward, acting as a moderate specification bump over the previous model.

Article Link: AirTag 1 vs. AirTag 2 Buyer's Guide: All 15+ Differences Compared
 
Last edited:
"Upgraded Bluetooth with increased range"

I presume the Bluetooth is how it communicates with various devices to be part of the Find My network. We don't get a percentage about how much better this is expected to be. What makes the range better? Is there increased power on the same frequencies? Does is have better range when contacting Find My network from inside a suitcase? Or in a wallet inside a bag? etc.
 
While I appreciate the detailed list of differences, the only significant ones are:
  1. 2nd generation ultra-wideband chip with newer Bluetooth for increased range, improved security, and compatibility with Apple Watch Precision Finding.
  2. Updated PCB and speaker design for a 50% louder volume, a G chime note instead of F, and increased tamper resistance.
  3. More difficult to accidentally reset.
  4. 7% heavier.
  5. Updated packaging and lettering on the back of the AirTag.
 
While I appreciate the detailed list of differences, the only significant ones are:
  1. 2nd generation ultra-wideband chip with newer Bluetooth for increased range, improved security, and compatibility with Apple Watch Precision Finding.
  2. Updated PCB and speaker design for a 50% louder volume, a G chime note instead of F, and increased tamper resistance.
  3. More difficult to accidentally reset.
  4. 7% heavier.
  5. Updated packaging and lettering on the back of the AirTag.
I would argue that #5 isn't significant either, although the reduction of plastic on the packaging is a small plus.

And honestly, given the minuscule amount of weight we're talking about, #4 isn't really significant either, though I'll agree it belongs on the list. 7% would be noticeable on an iPhone, but I would wager most humans are not capable of detecting a 0.8g weight difference in anything weighing more than a few grams.

It's a rumor site, so it's all kinda pointless and silly and therefore the overly-detailed list is on-brand and fine, but when I got to two separate items describing in unnecessary detail the subtle differences in the packaging I just assumed that the whole thing was horked out by a chatbot that was fed the articles on the topic to date, and not even edited.
 
It's pretty terrible that these don't have 5G as promised. Back to the drawing board, Tim Apple!

Promised? By whom?

Not to mention the physical impossibility* of a cellular connected GPS device of the same size, weight, and battery life.

If you truly need a cellular + GPS device, there's a bunch of options on Amazon. They're larger, need to be charged every week or two, and typically require a subscription.

Or buy an Apple Watch SE GPS + Cellular and use the Family Setup

* with present technology.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SFjohn
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.