Another Craigslist idiot.

[benflick]

Here he is!
Before you say he got a replacement, I already emailed him and he replied saying "no, I bought it brand new on August Xth"
O RLY?

 

[alphaod]

Well if it's unlocked it can't be new, but it could an honest mistake; seller may think it's new when he/she bought it.

 

[Gray-Wolf]

He could have bought it new, when he said he did, if it was from a store/dealer that still had one in inventory.