I didn't even catch GadgetGeek's post. And I agree, he is completely wrong/misinformed. Good equipment/care makes all the difference. I have a mono 1st edition Please Please Me by the Beatles from 1962, that is in good condition. There are some ticks and pops in it, but that record has more life in it than the new CD remaster of Please Please Me; and I get so much more joy out of listening to that 48 year old piece of vinyl than I do listening to the CD. Keep in mind I have a fairly expensive setup (it was expensive to me at least) that consists of: a Rega P7 turntable (~$2,700), with a Ortofon Kontrapunkt C cartridge (~$1,500), connected to a Rega Mira3 pre-amp (~$2,000) NAD T785 receiver (~$4,000), which outputs to two Paradigm Studio Reference S100 speakers (~$3,000 for a pair) (the entire system is 7.1, but limited to 2.0 for the vinyl playback). The other speakers are: a Paradigm Studio CC-690 center channel (~$1,500), four Paradigm Studio 20 book shelves (~$1,200 for a pair, two pairs) (they serve as the surrounds), and a Paradigm Studio Seismic 10" subwoofer (~$1,500). We have a 7.1 sound system.
So my system (excluding TV, Blu-Ray, CD Player, etc.) cost: ~$18,000, that's cheap by A/V standards
When you exclude the surround sound and stick to stereo (as I do when listening to vinyl) it cost ~$13,000
I've listened to some of my records on cheaper systems and their faults become more evident on lower end systems, but if you have the money and are willing to put it into A/V equipment, vinyl is the way to go IMO.
This luxury setup of mine (as my parents call it) was installed fairly recently, and is what I got for my 16th B-day instead of a car, I basically got to pick our basement theater equipment which I get to have once I have a place of my own; although I might be getting a car from a relative if they get a new car anytime soon.
Please understand that it is not necessary to sink nearly $20,000 in to a system for a good vinyl experience, it's not. But it is hard to go back once you experience a really nice system. Keep in mind that a few months ago, I was really happy with an old Technics turntable with a $100 cartridge, a $500 Pioneer receiver, a $100 NAD phono pre-amp, a $300 pair of low end Paradigm speakers (Atoms) they were phenomenal speakers for the price. I still thought even with that system that vinyl sounded better than CDs and downloads. If you have ticks and pops in your records it is okay, IMO; they almost give your record a personality of its' own, it makes it yours.
Don