Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Ion Tichy

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jul 22, 2020
5
3
I am getting increasingly annoyed with Apple products lately. There seems to be an aggressive trend towards disconnecting the users from the power over their own data and their own decisions concerning their need for security. A few examples:



* Safari is tripping you all the time since Catalina with highly questionable and overzealous 'security measures' that render it useless to work with. A good example would be sites like draw.io, which Safari broke on account of not handling the OAuth dialogues. This would not be a problem if I could tell it to not interfere (which I tried using the provided settings), but it does interfere. All .. the .. time. Very annoying. Bye Safari, welcome the need for another browser, which is ofc a pain to keep things in synch.



* Another pet peeve: enforcing 2-factor authentication on users without giving them an option to 'opt out'. The feature is flaky, super annoying and doesn't add anything of value if you only have one device (it displays the code on the same device). Heck, it still displays the code on the same device half the time. Why should I be forced to run around with a locatable device (like an iPhone) just to log on to a website? In all truthfulness, the feature to me introduces more security concerns than it solves. Do I get an options to opt out? They refuse! This is my security, I get to decide?!



* A fine example of refusing the user control over their own data comes with the new apps Music and Audiobooks. They force you to migrate your audiobooks over to the Books app and then disallow simple things like renaming your book titles?! Or try to organise a library in Music that grew over 20 years as a collection of various sources and formats. You can not even select a bunch of albums to delete them conveniently! It's a nightmare! Either someone is really, really bad at UI design, or this is another conscious decision to make it harder to access and control your own data. Most likely to drive them into their own media shops. Yet again your freedom to choose as a consumer is completely trampled on.



* Finally I would like to mention Apple's decisions to abandon entire swathes of users with perfectly fine hardware that was rendered useless by failing to support it with updates. Users paid for it, Apple has a moral duty to support these machines until the end of their lifespan, not as long as it is convenient. We live in times where planned obsolescence should be viewed as a criminal act against the environment and fraudulent. If I do not want to produce waste, why should Apple force me to? This is unacceptable!



The list goes on. Users are constantly forced to abandon control over their own data and relinquish the power to decide on the extend of their security to Apple. This stinks! In fact: after decades of swearing by Apple products, if this trend is not quickly reversed, this is the end of my relationship as a customer with Apple.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TiggrToo
So...by your logic, if someone still drives an Edsel, Ford has a moral obligation to supply parts and support for it. Rubbish.

As for Books, I converted mine to mp3 so now they are seen as music/audio files.
Music, well, that’s just a crappy design I hope they change soon. It’s pathetic.
 
So...by your logic, if someone still drives an Edsel, Ford has a moral obligation to supply parts and support for it. Rubbish.

I beg to differ. For one: we're living in times where obsolescence is a real problem. As long as the machine works it should not be rendered unusable by software updates. And then many people still drive old timers. Imagine Ford could flip a switch and stop your car after five years. That is what we are talking about. Of course nobody is asking them to keep spare parts forever. But they are not supposed to render your product unusable with the flip of a switch. Which is what is effectively happening.

As for Books, I converted mine to mp3 so now they are seen as music/audio files.
Music, well, that’s just a crappy design I hope they change soon. It’s pathetic.

Yeah, I'm doing that as well. But Music even sucks at handling this. Here's a few of the nice things that happened (I'm connected to Apple Music):
* Files that were added appeared greyed out, days after adding them. They effectively disappear (you can see them but not use them) even though you added them only days ago. No reason given, no way to fix. If I hadn't kept a copy of the originals, Music would have ****ed me again.
* You add albums and all looks fine. You turns your back and the ****ing bitch splits it up into two or sometimes three albums!! you have to go through the rigmarole of selecting all the spread about songs and force them back together.
* The above task is rendered difficult by this idiotic little design quirk: try searching for albums and then select a bunch of them at the same time ... you can't. That view, for some unfathomable reason, acts different from the "Recently Added" for example. It's not intuitive at all, but you can select albums there by using the command key.
* Not that anywhere now you can use the CMD+I shortcut anymore. Oh no siree. For some stupid reason beyond anyone's guess, that no longer works. You have to use the mouse, right-click and select 'Get Info' from your context menu. If that entry exists ...

The whole redesign is awful. I hate it's guts. And apart from design flaws, which make it unnecessarily hard to work with your music collection, it simply is full of catastrophic bugs. The kind that destroys your data.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: Parzival
1. Bugs happens, incompatibilities too.
2. It helps if someone is trying to log in with your account on another device or website.
3. Books could be much better, yes. Music is exactly like the old iTunes. Use the Filter field to search instead of the the search box.
4. Yes, it could be better. But it's not so bad. They ships security updates for 10 years on macOS and you get 6 years of updates on iOS.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.