Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Smartgnzfreak

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jul 18, 2024
3
4
I get it Apple watches are really good and they provide a tonne of health tracking features. But it tends to calculate the steps even if I am not walking!!!???!?!!

I mean like a few months back I rode a tomtom in Indonesia and I suddenly saw that the watch was calculating steps every time the vehicle was passing over a pothole. I mean wth
 
The watch isn’t some angel watching over your shoulder with a click counter for every step you take.

It’s got an accelerometer and a computer and some pretty good algorithms. The basic idea is that, if you’re moving (which you were in the tomtom) and there’s a sudden bounce (your potholes) then it assumes that that’s caused by your foot bouncing off the pavement … typically what one refers to as a “step.”

Any other pedometer is going to be susceptible to similar miscalculations. It’s simply not reasonable for an accelerometer strapped to your wrist to be able to detect every subtle distinction between you walking and your wrist moving in a way that’s not inconsistent with walking.

Nor is it intended to be perfect.

The fundamental purpose of the Watch’s step counter is to encourage you to lead an active life. If on one day you get credit for extra steps you didn’t actually take, who cares? And if you ride the tomtom every day, those “extra” steps become part of your baseline — meaning that the step trend will still tell you if you’re walking more or less over the course of weeks and months.

If you’re just looking for an excuse to snigger because you discovered that it’s not hard to fool the watch … may I suggest?

Go for a walk. With or without the watch, doesn’t matter — just go for a walk. Get up, get out, move around … feel the ground beneath your feet, hear the sounds, see the sights, breathe the air. Do so most days of the week. If you really feel like, it while you’re walking, contemplate what it means that the watch is or isn’t counting your steps, correctly or incorrectly. What is the significance of the way the watch is or isn’t counting? Can you do better? How might you go about improving it?

b&
 
Most watches today do the same, speaking from personal experience. My smart watch also counts my minimal movements as steps. Although it can be a bit annoying, there are quite a few wearables today that help in the long run!
 
I get it Apple watches are really good and they provide a tonne of health tracking features. But it tends to calculate the steps even if I am not walking!!!???!?!!

I mean like a few months back I rode a tomtom in Indonesia and I suddenly saw that the watch was calculating steps every time the vehicle was passing over a pothole. I mean wth
Apple products suck.
 
All devices have flaws....my old fitbit used to track walking while pushing a pushchair as cycling!
 
You want a watch that will give you 100 accuracy?? Bro are you new or what? with every jerk of you tomtom the pedometer thingi in your watch will be activated and will counyt is as a step
go to 2050 bro you might get better things
 
  • Like
Reactions: surfzen21
Okay, I'll bite, what's a "tomtom"? Google says it's a GPS satnav company, and even adding Indonesia as a search term only adds a few Indonesian restaurants with that phrase in their name.
 
I get it Apple watches are really good and they provide a tonne of health tracking features. But it tends to calculate the steps even if I am not walking!!!???!?!!

I mean like a few months back I rode a tomtom in Indonesia and I suddenly saw that the watch was calculating steps every time the vehicle was passing over a pothole. I mean wth


You already posted this.

Yeah, you'd think with the in-watch camera, the ability for the watch to automatically and invisibly hack into every local CCTV camera, and with Apple's real time satellite imagery applied on a per-watch basis for every watch, this should NEVER happen. Inexcusable.


It's almost like the watch is limited to using a series of in-watch sensors that it uses in order to determine whether those vibrations it feels are actually steps or not.
 
Okay, I'll bite, what's a "tomtom"? Google says it's a GPS satnav company, and even adding Indonesia as a search term only adds a few Indonesian restaurants with that phrase in their name.
They may have meant a tuk-tuk… 🙂

1721836251512.png



Edit:
Actually it looks like a Tom Tom is an electric Tuk Tuk.
link
 
  • Like
Reactions: skeptech and Bichon
Not a “glitch”, inside an ATV and got steps counted - got to understand how steps are counted - see post #2
 
I get it Apple watches are really good and they provide a tonne of health tracking features. But it tends to calculate the steps even if I am not walking!!!???!?!!

I mean like a few months back I rode a tomtom in Indonesia and I suddenly saw that the watch was calculating steps every time the vehicle was passing over a pothole. I mean wth
just for reference, what model running which software do you have?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.