I tried to do this but failed. the only way it will work is if they have 2 of the phones you want in stock at the time of check out because they cannot sell you the same exact item twice. Once you return the one bought on contract through personal pickup they have to send it back even if it is not opened.
Interesting since this is contrary to what others have reported, as well as contrary to what the store employee told me when I was asking about that.
Which ATL store was this?
I was phoneless until yesterday
The employee I spoke with was at Perimeter and this was last week. He was very clear that he could do the return/re-sell but that it had to be done quickly.
Okay now I'm curious - and maybe a little nosey - how did you end up phoneless from ordering for in-store pickup on contract and then being unable to return/rebuy the same phone? What happened to the phone you'd had before?
they had already sent my 5s back
Short answer, yes it can be done. Find yourself a specialist in store and be sincere about what you're looking to do AFTER they bring out the phone from the back (assuming you reserved online for 2-year contract). If they give you attitude, find someone else or speak with a manager. I got very lucky and was paired up with an extremely patient and informed staff member.
If they are unfamiliar with the process, mention that you heard (through the interwebs) that what youre looking to do can be processed through an OPEN BOX return. If they do a standard return it immediately goes back into the general inventory queue and you'll lose the device. They will require you to complete the transaction and pay the subsidized price at first and then refund the full amount to your credit card. Then, they need to run some AT&T software that basically reinstates your upgrade eligibility following the refund. FYI, this takes awhile to sync with the server so have patience. Once cleared you will be able to repurchase the device under the plan of your liking I went with AT&T Next 12. You should leave the store with 3 separate receipts (#1) purchase on 2-year contract, (#2) refund on 2-year contract, and (#3) purchase on Next. In total, the entire process takes about an hour so come prepared with some other Apple questions to fill the time.
I was able to upgrade through AT&T Next last week to an iPhone 6 Plus on AT&T and reserved online for 2-year contract as Ive had ZERO success finding these available in store. Im very happy with my decision, the device is incredible! Good luck and let me know if you have any questions.
Quite a story, glad you got it sorted out in the end.
This is exactly why I hate the trade-in promos, especially around launch time. Constrains your options if the new phone isn't the perfect match since you can't simply switch back to your old phone.
be sincere about what you're looking to do AFTER they bring out the phone from the back [...] what you’re looking to do can be processed through an OPEN BOX return.
you would think they have some type of protocol for this since you have 14 days to return the device but they don't.
Excellent information, thank you for posting.
What I think is they know very well what they're doing...
it's to their advantage to make buyers less likely to do a return. Someone on the fence may just svck it up and keep the device rather than go through the hassle of being without a phone or buying/borrowing an alternate.
Not to mention the programs lower the barrier for phone upgrades for those without cash reserves or sufficient credit to bridge the transition of buying the new phone and selling the old one.