Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

jon08

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Nov 14, 2008
1,893
109
On S3 usually I'd burn 450-530 ACTIVE kcal during a 45-50 min HIIT exercise, with avg. heart rate ranging between 136-142.

Then I bought S4 and the first time I used it I got similar results as with S3.

However, then I decided to reset calibration data and recalibrate the new watch, because, well it's a new watch so I wanted to do the proper calibration. (I did two 20-min outdoor walks in Workout out in the open as suggested by Apple to calibrate the watch).

After that, the next time I did similar HIIT exercise as before the watch tracked ONLY 167 ACTIVE kcal (!!) in 50 mins. How can that be possible? This is way too low. Heart rate was tracked alright, no gaps. Avg. heart rate 133.

Today was the 2nd time after resetting watch calibration and the results after a similar HIIT training were slightly better: it showed 296 ACTIVE kcal burned. Avg. heart rate 140.

However, this is still way less than before I reset the calibration when it logged 450-530 ACTIVE kcal during the training.

Could it be that the watch is still in the process of "learning" and that after a couple more trainings it will display the kcal correctly again? Please advise.

PS: for the record, my personal metrics in Health app are up-to-date.
 
Last edited:
Not knowing your age or weight, I would say the new numbers are more accurate. Average heart rate of 140 is not very high.
 
Ok, looks like the watch is adjusting to my body. Did another HIIT exercise today and the calorie count was already much better now: 442 ACTIVE kcal in 47 mins...
 
Ok, looks like the watch is adjusting to my body. Did another HIIT exercise today and the calorie count was already much better now: 442 ACTIVE kcal in 47 mins...
Based on what I've seen on various charts, I would guesstimate an honest HIIT workout to come in at 8.0 MET.

For a 145 lb person and a 50 minute workout, the formulas suggest a burn of 460 kcal. Not sure if that includes the resting calories or not, but it's in the ballpark of what your S3 used to register and what your S4 is doing currently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jon08
Based on what I've seen on various charts, I would guesstimate an honest HIIT workout to come in at 8.0 MET.

For a 145 lb person and a 50 minute workout, the formulas suggest a burn of 460 kcal. Not sure if that includes the resting calories or not, but it's in the ballpark of what your S3 used to register and what your S4 is doing currently.
Thanks for your input. Sounds quite close to what I got today! I’m curious what I’ll be getting next time and I’ll post the result here.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.