Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mike7135

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 16, 2020
2
0
I've got a Late 2011 17" i7 MBP which i've acquired as it was marked as dead and destined for the bin. I dont know how long it's been sat 'dead', but i'd guess at at least 4 years or so.

After a bit of googling and looking through the forums, i determined it was the DC-IN board that had failed. Bought a new one and replaced it. Was a bit concerned as the new one had smaller wires going to the plug than the original, and also one screw hole was in a very slightly different position (so i've only got it held in with one screw). I've put both of these things down to just being aftermarket part. Anyway, fitted the new board, and the MBP fired up and all seemed well.

Only issue i could notice was it was charging slowly - but put this down to the fact the battery had probably been empty for a few years.

So, left it most of the day yesterday charging and it got to about 70%. I switched off the charger overnight and while at work today as didnt want to leave it unattended.
For info, the battery shows only 89 cycles from new, with a 95% of new capacity and said good health.
Came to it today, and turned the charger on and left it for an hour or so. Came back to it and it showed fully charged (green light on MagSafe) - which seems quicker than it was charging yesterday.

Unplugged charger, turned on the MBP. It got to about 80% of the loading bar and then died. Have now plugged the charger back in and it boots okay, and shows battery 81% charged, but says "replace now" and "battery is not charging".

Have tried resetting SMC, disconnecting and reconnecting battery, etc, but battery now appears to be dead. If i press the battery test button (with MagSafe plugged in), all 5 lights flash. If i press it with the battery disconnected (and MagSafe plugged in), again all 5 lights flash.

Is it that i was just unlucky and the first bit of stress on the battery for probably about 4 years has killed it, despite seeming okay, or is something else possibly giving issues?

Any thoughts, suggestions, etc very much appreciated.

Sorry for long waffle - just wanted to give as many details as possible. Many thanks. :)
 
1. sitting dead for so long isn't good for a battery. It's probably not very happy
2. you might need to run a few cycle through the battery for the system to calibrate.
 
Thanks.

What confused me is I'd expect it just not to charge and/or hold charge after sitting empty for ages, but seemed to charge and hold charge for all of a day, then just went.

Unable to put cycles on the battery now though, as the system neither charges or runs off the battery.

I'm just a bit worried about buying a new battery in case it was the new dc-in board or something that killed the current one, and it'll do it again.
... Or if the dc board was problematic, would it just not run at all?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.