Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Juan007

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Jun 14, 2010
786
945
Amazing that the AirPods 4th Gen can be total crap, completely useless for anyone doing any athletic activity, while the Beats Pro Fit surpasses any AirPods I have ever used, by far, even models that came out much more recently (Beats Pro Fit is a ~4 yr old model?).

The only bad thing I can say about Beats Pro Fit is the case looks like it was designed in about 2005 with about 5 cents worth of plastic. It looks and feels like junk. Of course, the case is about .0001% of the user experience, so does it really matter?

EVERYTHING else about Beats Pro Fit is amazing. The fit is perfect. I went for a run today, I didn't have to adjust them even once, and I even set a new PR. They stay in, they don't fall out. INCREDIBLE improvement over garbage AirPods Gen 4.

The BUTTONS on the Beats Pro Fit ACTUALLY WORK, you can actually press them with intent, they are real buttons not some garbage taptic nonsense that MISDETECTS TOUCHES as button presses. The "buttons" on the AirPods were worse than useless, the buttons on the Pro Fit are actually USEFUL. Yes, imagine that Tim Cook, buttons that are actually USEFUL TO THE USER. Who would have imagined that?!?

Unfortunately for Apple, the comparison here between Beats Pro Fit and the newest AirPods shows just how much the mighty have fallen. Dr. Dre is a MUSIC PRODUCER and rapper, yet he is able to out-engineer Tim Cook and crew, supposedly the best product designers in the world?!? How did this happen??? And yes, I know Beats is owned by Apple, but the design is straight from Dre. It is LIGHT YEARS better than the Apple design. It's not even close.

TIM COOK - stop making user-hostile product. I don't care what you have to do, fire yourself and make Dr. Dre the new CEO. What you are doing IS NOT WORKING. You are making garbage and your users are fed up. You are getting out-designed by a RAPPER (a great rapper, but still).
 
  • Haha
Reactions: GMShadow
Are you aware that Beats Pro Fit are designed specifically for the purposes you describe, whereas AirPods are not? Apple lets the Beats and AirPods brands each do its own thing, they could have shut Beats down years ago (they bought it from Dr. Dre in 2014, Dre is seemingly not actively involved anymore).
 
Are you aware that Beats Pro Fit are designed specifically for the purposes you describe, whereas AirPods are not? Apple lets the Beats and AirPods brands each do its own thing, they could have shut Beats down years ago (they bought it from Dr. Dre in 2014, Dre is seemingly not actively involved anymore).

Dre leads the QA software teams at Apple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sunapple
The only bad thing I can say about Beats Pro Fit is the case
Agreed. It's too big, too slippery, and nearly impossible to open with one hand.

[EDIT] There is a second bad thing, though, and actually worse than the case. The wingtips can tear, so if you just bought yours, I suggest paying the $30 for Apple Care, and be extra careful about not handling them by the wingtips. Be very careful when you wipe them clean, as it's very easy to stress the wingtip. Both of mine were replaced under Apple Care, but the only way to avoid a service fee under AC is to drop them at the Apple Store and pick them up when the replacements arrive.
The fit is perfect. I went for a run today, I didn't have to adjust them even once, and I even set a new PR. They stay in, they don't fall out.
Agreed. And third party tips are available.
The BUTTONS on the Beats Pro Fit ACTUALLY WORK
My favorite feature. I live in a cold climate and love being able to use the buttons while wearing gloves and a knit cap under a hoodie.
 
Last edited:
Are you aware that Beats Pro Fit are designed specifically for the purposes you describe, whereas AirPods are not?
Completely and utterly FALSE, go watch the original AirPods keynote and you will see PROFESSIONAL ATHLETES doing their thing while wearing AirPods. They were DESIGNED for athletes but somewhere down the line Timmy & Co decided to increase profit margins (?) or maybe decided to re-market AirPods to people that haven't touched grass since Obama was president (because if you lean over an touch grass, your AirPods Gen 4 WILL Fall out).

I will correct you though because there is a hint of truth in what you wrote:

BOTH the AirPods and Beats Pro Fit are designed specifically for the purpose I describe (running / athletics).

The Beats Pro Fit are a SUCCESSFUL DESIGN.

The AirPods Gen 4 are an ABJECT FAILURE.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: iDaniel88
Completely and utterly FALSE, go watch the original AirPods keynote and you will see PROFESSIONAL ATHLETES doing their thing while wearing AirPods. They were DESIGNED for athletes but somewhere down the line Timmy & Co decided to increase profit margins (?) or maybe decided to re-market AirPods to people that haven't touched grass since Obama was president (because if you lean over an touch grass, your AirPods Gen 4 WILL Fall out).

I will correct you though because there is a hint of truth in what you wrote:

BOTH the AirPods and Beats Pro Fit are designed specifically for the purpose I describe (running / athletics).

The Beats Pro Fit are a SUCCESSFUL DESIGN.

The AirPods Gen 4 are an ABJECT FAILURE.
Don’t be fooled by Apple’s marketing. They always act like AirPods are a perfect fit that will never fall out but everyone has different ears of course.

Trust your own logic. Beats have wingtips. AirPods don’t. So the Beats serve a specific purpose and AirPods are for general use.

I’m stating the obvious here but this was my reasoning for my comment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iDaniel88
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.