The only thing i do not like about booq sleeve is inside foam or pad is so thin if it was a little bit thicker i would go with booq but i choosed this one its greet
i had the neoprene sleeve by incase and it was pretty good, it was a very tight fit for my mbp15. it melted slightly after sitting on a radiator and i bought a vyper m3 to replace it. the vyper is the best case i have ever owned. it was worth every penny and i recommend it to anyone who uses a laptop
the vyper hands down. it may have thin foam but it doesn't need much because of the ballistic nylon exterior.
a little mentioned bonus of the vyper or other such styled cases, is that once you take out your mbp, if you zip the case up it works as a PERFECT lap cushion. aka put your mbp on top of it and you won't burn your legs