I’ve got both of these (and the Clover one). All of them look great! You can’t go wrong with either one. The Apple logo on the Abyss Blue case matches the camera module that’s visible in the cutout, so it looks really nice.
I bought my cases discounted from the Amazon Warehouse. Two of them were unopened returns; the 3rd was opened, but still looked brand new. Just a suggestion if you want to get multiple cases without paying full price for all of them.