This is a common issue with the PowerMac G5 because of the age and that is, when it's stored for long periods of time, it will start to act like it boots up perfectly fine some of the time, but some of the time it boots up and the fan revs up on high. I have seen several of these PowerMac G5s exhibiting these issues while working at the non-profit recycling facility and recycling them for sale and they all point to either a logic board problem or an imminent power supply problem. My first dual PowerMac G5 died because of the logic board issue. My second single 1.8Ghz PowerMac G5 with a more reliable logic board died when the power supply blew up. It was showing the symptoms 6 months with 90% booting up to desktop while 10% of the time, the fan revs up and did nothing until I shut it off and then powering on again. Then one day, I heard a big bang while working with the G5 and I can see smoke coming out of the fan ports and the smell of blown caps.
Usually those video cards on the Dual 2.3 are reliable as that was my thought as well when diagnosing those machines, but it turned out to be mainly power supply issues as well as the logic board. Just sharing my experience with you so you don't buy a video card only ending up not solving the issue. You may try the diagnostic procedure listed below out of the G5 service manual for your Dual 2.3 to isolate your particular issue.
" Power-On Self Test: RAM and Processor Verification
A power-on self test in the computer’s ROM automatically runs whenever the computer is started up after being fully shut down (the test does not run if the computer is only restarted). If the test
detects a problem, the status LED located above the power button on the front of the computer will flash in the following ways*:
1 Flash: No RAM is installed or detected.
2 Flashes: Incompatible RAM types are installed or RAM installed in wrong slots.
3 Flashes: No RAM banks passed memory testing.
4 Flashes: No good boot images are detected in the boot ROM (and/or there is a bad sys config block).
5 Flashes: The processor is not usable.
- Note: The status LED lights up when the power button is depressed at startup. Do not count this light as one of the diagnostic flashes.
Diagnostic LEDs
Power Mac G5 (Late 2005) logic boards include a set of LEDs to help service providers troubleshoot the computers. The LEDs are located to the left of the top bank of DIMM slots.
Power-on LED illuminates when power button is pressed and fans spin continuously but there is no boot tone or video
Reseat video card. (Make sure video card is fully inserted in connector and end of card is secured by the connector latch.) For video cards that require power cables, check that they are connected.
Verify speaker cable is fully seated.
Reset logic board. Refer to “Resetting the Logic Board” in this chapter.
Check diagnostic LED 1 and LED 6 for processor connection
Replace processor
Replace logic board
Power-on LED illuminates when power button is pressed, fans spin, and boot tone chimes, but there is no video
Reseat video card. (Make sure video card is fully inserted in connector and end of card is secured by the connector latch.) For NVIDIA Quadro FX 4500 graphics card, check that power cord for card is connected.
Reset PRAM (restart computer while holding down Command-Option-P-R keys until second boot tone chimes)
Reset logic board. Refer to “Resetting the Logic Board” in this chapter.
Replace video card
Replace logic board