Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

simX

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
May 28, 2002
766
4
Bay Area, CA
What are people's experiences with DVD-ripping software? I have a DVD that was made for me using footage from a video camera, and I want to rip the DVD into a QuickTime-friendly movie file. It's a DVD+R, too, which seems to complicate things a bit.

I've tried forty-two, which doesn't work too well (the qDVD option doesn't work for some reason, and neither does the regular DVD option -- and I don't want to make an AVI file that isn't QuickTime friendly, since most aren't). I also tried DVDxDV, but that's a trial version and pastes a watermark on any video you export (plus it has a poor UI and doesn't seem to create great movie files). I haven't found any other software that's suitable for ripping DVDs and not just copying them.

Any ideas?
 
Handbrake is the way to go.

DVDBackup will just remove the encryption and place a copy on your HD, which can then be burnt to a DVD (or compressed and then burnt).

Handbrake of Forty Two are your best bets. Forty Two worked flawless for me, but you claim to experience difficulty. Handbrake has gotten rave reviews, but I haven't tried it, so I'd give that a go.

i may be mistaken, but i thought 0Sex had an option to rip dvd's into one large MP4...or maybe that was Forty Two.
 
neoelectronaut said:

Handbrake worked perfectly for me. It's also a nice Mac OS X application -- drag and drop install, nice icon, and it actually has a useful UI. Simple, elegant, useful. Thanks for the recommendation!
 
simX said:
Handbrake worked perfectly for me. It's also a nice Mac OS X application -- drag and drop install, nice icon, and it actually has a useful UI. Simple, elegant, useful. Thanks for the recommendation!

Glad to be of help. :)
 
Riot_Mac said:
dvdbackup and then dvd2oneX and then toast to burn it to a dvd.
or you could use a program called DVDRemaster which was designed on the OS X platform, and is cheaper. i have nothing to do with them, i just believe in supporting os x developers, not porters of old versions of pc software at twice the price. DVD2OneX reached as high as $70, after DVDRemaster came out it dropped back to $35 to be competitive. It's really a personal choice, but I've had nothing but success with DVDRemaster.

also, toast is quite expensive if you don't already own it, and the extra functionality isn't necessary. DVDImager is freeware, and will instantly create an img file for you. Go to Disk Utility, the Images menu, and Burn!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.