Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

lugesm

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Sep 7, 2007
572
9
I accidentally came across a reference to Bit Torrent, and I checked their web site.

This must be the "Napster" of today. Is this site allowing the exchange of protected media?

Is it legal?
 
hmm is file-sharing of protected media legal?
no, not to flame but cmon. and learn about bittorent cuz its the best
 
Linky

basically its a P2P file transfer system, and yer certain torrents are legal like some game updates and companies have their free software available via torrents.

There is also a MASSIVE illegal community sharing everything from tv to software.
 
Its a great distribution method for software from devs unwilling/able to pay the huge bandwidth costs associated with popular and regularly updated software. E.g. Linux distros and NeoOffice.
 
World of Warcraft uses it to distribute their patches.

There is even a few legal video on demand services that use it. Verizon (and maybe comcast) are also starting to use it.
 
I accidentally came across a reference to Bit Torrent, and I checked their web site.

This must be the "Napster" of today. Is this site allowing the exchange of protected media?

Is it legal?
The "Napster" of today is Limewire.
 
I accidentally came across a reference to Bit Torrent, and I checked their web site.

This must be the "Napster" of today. Is this site allowing the exchange of protected media?

Is it legal?

I read on a gadget website where a woman read about how to download torrents and then she downloaded a bunch of movies. She got a notice from Comcast telling her to stop what she was doing. I don't think the said they were going to press charges but they threatened.

I wish I remembered where I saw that so I could show you.

But it is a HUGE community.
 
hmm is file-sharing of protected media legal?
no, not to flame but cmon.

Agreed. We all know that sharing of copyrighted media is not legal! However, I didn't get far enough into that site to see the actual content. My question, perhaps not perfectly stated, regarded whether Bit Torrent might offer useful (legal) information posted there.

I really didn't want to download and install some program from Bit Torrent or any other site without knowing more.
 
ya i would say that just about everyone I have encountered that uses torrents, uses them illegally
 
I read on a gadget website where a woman read about how to download torrents and then she downloaded a bunch of movies. She got a notice from Comcast telling her to stop what she was doing. I don't think the said they were going to press charges but they threatened.

Of course, Comcast cares for other reasons:

1) It's a bandwidth hog that chokes their network (or at least that's the reason they've given for throttling bittorrent access).

2) They want to slow the adoption of internet-based entertainment since it competes with cable tv.

3) They are potentially indirectly liable for assisting in copyright infringement.

Personally, I'm guessing the letter came primarily for reason #1.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.