Saddle brown is a winner.
That said I returned mine yesterday because I already have a midnight blue and felt the $69 could go to better use.
Whilst there, I asked about whether my 8 month old case was meant to have such wear and tear to the point you see the plastic. The guy replaced it without even blinking. So I walked out with a brand new case just by asking and being friendly.
Apple = win (if you get the right person to help you)