I'm using right now one of those old, bad LCDs that supposedly had so short a lifespan. It's only 10 year old (!) and I don't know about the brightness (impossible to notice the difference during so long a time), but it doesn't seem dim. Granted, it's rather small and has lower resolution than a MacBook, but it works. I think people worry too much about longevity of these things; I don't know any statistics, but it seems they're more likely to fail because of random reasons rather than die while you're still using them.