Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Dartamis

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Aug 15, 2006
17
0
I have a project I want to do in HD but I want to include some SD clips. Can FCP upscale and crop those clips to match 1080? I understand that they will not look as good as the HD but I just want them to fill the screen at least.
 
I have a project I want to do in HD but I want to include some SD clips. Can FCP upscale and crop those clips to match 1080? I understand that they will not look as good as the HD but I just want them to fill the screen at least.

Yeah, but I think you have to do it manually. You just drop a SD clip inside of a HD timeline, and just go to your Motion tab, and scale it up to fill the screen. It probably look really terrible though, and comparable to a TV scaling 480i to 720p/1080i/1080p. :(
 
Yeah, but I think you have to do it manually. You just drop a SD clip inside of a HD timeline, and just go to your Motion tab, and scale it up to fill the screen. It probably look really terrible though, and comparable to a TV scaling 480i to 720p/1080i/1080p. :(

OK so then my next question is does anyone know of a good tool to use for upscaling SD?
 
OK so then my next question is does anyone know of a good tool to use for upscaling SD?

Regardless of what you use, you'll never get true HD resolution, or improvement in image quality if you're asking. To get HD res, shoot in HD. Otherwise, use the native resolution of SD. Besides, if you upconvert SD to HD, not only will you get a much bigger file for no reason, but you'll also lose quality in the process. Everytime you re-encode a file, you lose quality.
 
Regardless of what you use, you'll never get true HD resolution, or improvement in image quality if you're asking. To get HD res, shoot in HD. Otherwise, use the native resolution of SD. Besides, if you upconvert SD to HD, not only will you get a much bigger file for no reason, but you'll also lose quality in the process. Everytime you re-encode a file, you lose quality.

I know it won't look like HD. I'm not aiming for that. The bulk of the project will be shot in HD but I just have to throw in some older footage that happends to be SD. I just want it to fill the screen without it looking like a muddy mess.
 
I know it won't look like HD. I'm not aiming for that. The bulk of the project will be shot in HD but I just have to throw in some older footage that happends to be SD. I just want it to fill the screen without it looking like a muddy mess.

Well in that case, looks like you have two options for that. Scale it up in FCP, or use InstantHD. You could probably use some filters to tweak the scaled image if it looks like crappy.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.