It's not ridiculous at all. First off, of course they need an ATV. Do you think the Airport Extreme is going to display itself on the TV? But the fact that the Airport Extreme doesn't connect with the ATV to provide files without a computer to intervene is completely idiotic. EVERY other set top box does that. Even the PS4 and XBox One are doing this in the coming upgrades and THEY are gaming consoles.
The ENTIRE point of an ATV is to serve video, picture and music to the TV...That's all. It has no other function. So it needs to do that function better that something else, otherwise it becomes redundant. My upstairs TV is a hacked ATV2 and the only reason it still lives is because the jailbreak allows me to connect to DLNA and file servers like the Airport Extreme without a computer being on. My ATV3, being unable to be jailbroken, is useless and I can't even find a buyer on Kijiiji for $50. Shows you how in demand they are...not.
If you are buying anything for playing video, music or pictures, an Apple TV is not the thing to buy until Apple fixes that problem. You can't play AVI files, MKV files, WMV files unless you convert them. It works with most, but not all MP3 files and MP4 files, but there are some out there that still fail. I, for example, used to have a digital video cam that recorded in AVI. I have probably 300 home videos which cannot play on the ATV without conversion. So I COULD buy a $50 program to convert them, spend 5 hours getting it done, then play on the ATV. OR I could just play them on any other set top box on my "not so Smart" TV or directly on my Smart TV.
Apple is great for many things, but the ATV is not one of those things. Don't defend them for a faulty thing, when what they really need to do is make a simple fix. But they have moved on to other things and there will be no more ATV's. They will be releasing a real TV (actual screen) instead and it will probably be awesome, IF they learn from their ATV mistakes. But if people just tell them what they want to hear "Ooooh, Apple is good, Apple is great, Apple is god!!", then nothing ever gets improved on.
>>That is an absolutely ridiculous comment! The majority of my content I didn't buy from Apple and yet I have no problem playing it on Apple products. Rather than dumping on Apple for not supporting every conceivable device configuration, why not point out to the OP that they don't even need the ATV to accomplish what they need?<<