Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Does RAID 0 slow boot time (2011 Mini Server)?

D

donklaus

macrumors member
Original poster
Mar 6, 2011
69
10
I have been setting up my new mini server over the past few days, including setting up RAID 0 before ever booting up from the boot drive for the first time (Carbon Copy cloned it before I even started).

Pretty disappointed. The boot time from a cold start is excruciatingly slow, far slower than the Santa Rosa C2D (2.4 ghz) MBP it replaces as my desktop machine. I installed 8 gigs of RAM before even powering it up.

What's the deal?
 
Steps to take to diagnose:

1. Test the throughput off the RAID, you may have a bum drive in the array.

2. If the results seem normal for a RAID 0 with the type of drives you have, use verbose mode to check the startup process for irregularities.
 
donklaus said:
I have been setting up my new mini server over the past few days, including setting up RAID 0 before ever booting up from the boot drive for the first time (Carbon Copy cloned it before I even started).

Pretty disappointed. The boot time from a cold start is excruciatingly slow, far slower than the Santa Rosa C2D (2.4 ghz) MBP it replaces as my desktop machine. I installed 8 gigs of RAM before even powering it up.

What's the deal?
Click to expand...

Do you have the drive selected as the startup drive in Start Disk:System Preferences? Does it sit there for a while before you see the Apple logo on boot up?

RAID 0 should pretty much double your read and write speeds.
 
donklaus said:
I have been setting up my new mini server over the past few days, including setting up RAID 0 before ever booting up from the boot drive for the first time (Carbon Copy cloned it before I even started).

Pretty disappointed. The boot time from a cold start is excruciatingly slow, far slower than the Santa Rosa C2D (2.4 ghz) MBP it replaces as my desktop machine. I installed 8 gigs of RAM before even powering it up.

What's the deal?
Click to expand...
I have noticed the same thing with my 2011 mac mini server as well. Once I delete the RAID and install Lion on just one drive the boot time is cut in half.

I am thinking it has something to do with Lion and the Recovery paritions and what not.


I also noticed that when in the RAID - my mini will boot up spin a bit on the gray screen and then reboot again. This is resolved once i remove the RAID and just use one HD.
 
Thanks all

I'll try those when I get home tonight and report back on any results.
 
I'll test it tonight when I get my replacement mini server before I put it into RAID 0.

However, honestly, why not have the boot time hurt slightly if you gain everyday performance boost while using your computer when running?

I don't see the reason to be completely powering down a mini server very often.
 
I have a 2011 Mac Mini Server using RAID 0 and have not noticed a difference in boot time. The install was performed using Internet Recovery. RAID 0 with hard drives will not improve boot time significantly like using a single SSD. Throughput does not account for much of OS load process. The large number of processes and files that need to be touched for booting is the issue, hence SSDs greatly improve performance because of higher IOPs and virtually no seek time. RAID will actually increase the seek time.
 
something's wrong with your setup. it only takes mine about 35-40 seconds to boot up, from chime to desktop. and i have a lot of startup items, launchagents, and daemons. of course, i only reboot about once a month or whenever a software update requires it. otherwise i seriously would never reboot.
 
Found the main problem at least

Turns out my Time Machine disk, which I had used on my previous machine right up to the last day before I transferred everything to the new Mini, was the problem. Haven't determined if the problem is mechanical or not, but Disk Utility can't fix it. Disconnected it and the boot time is now pretty reasonable - I haven't timed it, but its on par with my MBP which boots in around 30 seconds. Thanks for the tips, all.
 
Yep, external drives can cause all kind of hiccups. I have several attached. Every 1-2 years when I start to see something funny, I try to remember to look at my externals first.
 
chrfr said:
With RAID 0, if you have a "bum drive" you have no data.
Click to expand...

I meant "bum" in the sense of a drive not performing properly. Drive have more than two states you know. If i had said "dead" drive you would have a point, but alas...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back