Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

kashyap02004

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 28, 2011
88
0
I know that the MBP unibody acts as heat sink. I have the speck case. It covers the entire under-body and screen-back of MBP. Does it resist the cooling process???

Speck_13-inch_SeeThru_Case_for_Aluminum_MacBook__47166_zoom.jpg
 
Last edited:
i haven't had any issues... mine only gets up near 80c when gaming (though i have seen slightly lower temps without the case.)
 
So, should I use it or not?

If you aren't doing intensive applications that will cause the fans to turn on, then yea, I don't see a problem.

If you don't yet, get smcFanControl and see how the temperature is when you're using the computer; if you never (or rarely) hear the fans on your computer now, chances are you won't have a problem.

The good part is is that Speck cases has a vent which can release heat produced by the MBP

That doesn't help the restriction it puts on the unit as a whole to help dissipate heat. The aluminum conducts heat and helps cool the system. Putting plastic on it keeps that heat in. Kind of like... wrapping your body in plastic but leaving your head open to sweat. Your entire body sweats, not just your head.
 
I had one of those and it turned my computer into a pile of oozing goo. Wouldn't recommend it, mostly because I no longer have legs
 
If you aren't doing intensive applications that will cause the fans to turn on, then yea, I don't see a problem.

If you don't yet, get smcFanControl and see how the temperature is when you're using the computer; if you never (or rarely) hear the fans on your computer now, chances are you won't have a problem.



That doesn't help the restriction it puts on the unit as a whole to help dissipate heat. The aluminum conducts heat and helps cool the system. Putting plastic on it keeps that heat in. Kind of like... wrapping your body in plastic but leaving your head open to sweat. Your entire body sweats, not just your head.

Better than not having a vent nor a case.
Id rather have a hot MBP than a dented or scratched one.
 
i got the same blue one. It's nice to have. I'm sure it does do produce a bit of heat, because it is an enclosure. One of my peeves about it is when i'm using my macbook in bed laying down, the extra weight of the top cover on top of my macbook screen causes the screen to close. The hinge on my 2011 macbook isnt as strong compared to my 2008 one.
 
I have been gaming with my speck case and it causes the laptop to be a little hotter, however it saves me burning my legs.

I like the case but it does significantly increase the weight of the laptop. However I am happy to put up with the weight, as a dog owner this case is saving me from a lot of tiny accidents and scrapes that would other wise happen when the laptop is laying around.
 
I don't really get the case thing. The machine is already pretty sturdy. If you need to carry it, use a good bag instead rather than have a case on it all the time.
 
It's what's inside that counts

I did the following. I took off my case and then got iStat. iStat told me that my CPU was running at about 195 degrees F. My fan was running at 5700 RPM. I then ran top -o cpu from my terminal and showed me that mds (Spotlight) was my number one CPU hog. I then disabled mds using the command launchctl unload as documented over at osxdaily.com

Just to be sure, I put my macbook pro up an at angle to increase the flow of air under the machine. Within about 3 minutes the cpu temperature went down 40 degrees and the fan slowed to 2400 RPM. This made the fan inaudible in an office environment.

I then replaced the case and set the machine back to flat. The temperature continued to drop and the fan speed went all the way to 2000, at which point I began to write this message. Now Chrome is my CPU hog and the temperature is up to 162 degrees with the fan running at about 3000 RPM, which is barely audible.

I conclude that what's running on your CPU is much more important than your skin, or the angle of your machine. And it might also be that the case dampens the noise from the fan without restricting airflow.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.