DOT-POD Developer Note:
Hi all,
oldschool, I am sure that most web servers world wide contain copyright material somewhere on the computer but it's up to each user not to publish copyright material. It would be just as illegal to use OSX Web-Sharing or Apache to publish copyright material. Also it's not really as easy as you may think for the average musician to publish their tracks via Web-Sharing. Just because you and I know how to create html pages with links to tracks, create formatted tables to professionally present the work, enable authentication to only allow certain people to download and create a database to allow fast searching - doesn't mean the average musician can do all this....If it was easy then the DOT-POD download figures and registrations would be nowhere near as high as they are. Checkout the downloads on MacUpdate, VersionTracker and Download.com and you'll see that for the non IT minded - DOT-POD is awesome!
Sure, DOT-POD can publish a musicians entire iPod as Apache can publish an entire hard drive. Where does the responsibility of the user come into this debate. Can we not sell Web-Servers, CD burners, Knives, cars, mobile phones with cameras and sound recorders, cameras or movie cameras ... just incase a criminal uses them? If an illegal adult web site is published using Apache, how responsible are the Apache developers? I say 'they are not responsible at all' what do you think?
Santaduck, I can assure you, there is a huge base of professional and amateur musicians using iTunes and the iPod. I haven't revealed this to the group yet - but we are actually professional musicians with currently more than 600 original musical works being broadcast around the globe. We have been using iPods for around 2 years now to transport our own original music to and from the studio. Now we just broadcast it to each other using DOT-POD. And my iPod currently has 0 songs which below to other composers.
Now, AppleJustWorks ... I hope that my explanations above have helped. Can you see any reason why I am breaking the law? Gosh, I don't even have any other peoples music on my iPod. If I have a CD burner would you assume I use it to copy other peoples work? If I have a tape recorder do you wonder if I take it into concerts and record their music? Do I take my video recorder into movies and pirate their work? Even rope is illegal if you use it to strangle someone.
The way the law works is that you are innocent until you break the law. Simple. DOT-POD isn't illegal just because it exists or if I use it to publish my own work. But if I use DOT-POD, Web-Sharing, Apache, Tomcat, IIS, or any other web server to publish copyright material then I would be breaking the law.
Music software which has been in the spotlight recently regarding copyright infringements is due to 1 of 2 reasons.
1) The software affects the operation of someone else's software (ie iTunes/Apple and various plugins developed to open up sharing - DOT-POD does not interfere or interact with any Apple software)
2) The software developer is involved in the process of copyright infringement (like these large file sharing networks - where the developer sits in the middle sharing IP address to facilitate connection of remote users - DOT-POD doesn't work like this either)
I hope this helps
Happy Easter
Jeff
DOT-POD