DVD±R/RW drives are dual media; DVD-R is Mac; Apple, Verbatim & Ritek
SpaceMagic said:
(A) Can anyone tell me what's the difference between DVD+R and DVD-R.
(B) Which one does the G5's SuperDrive burn?
(C) And which ones can be read (for data) in the G5? Then,

, can anyone
(D) recommend a brand which are generally reliable, and cheap
ANSWERS: Early in March, I did a study on the
availability of DVD±R media in the USA, Canada, UK and Europe, including sale of
8x & 4x DVD-R & DVD+R, and their street prices.
(A) Pioneer, Plextor and others were the developers & manufacturers of
DVD-R format, which was the first format.
Sony, Philips and some other manufacurers came up with a competing
format, DVD+R, which lagged
Apple's pioneering use in computers, but when the DVD+R was adopted by Dell Computer (which sells 100,000 per DAY!), DVD+R drives and media suddenly flooded the market.
(B) Your G5 SuperDrive is most likely a Pioneer 4x DVR-A06 or DVR-106 drive, which you can easily check in
System Profiler.
DVD-R is more compatible with Movie DVD software and hardware that play them or have been around for awhile.
Today, virtually every major manufacturer builds a cross±platform laser drive, which you will see as
DVD±R/RW
Since October 2003, and more recently this month,
Apple has lowered its
"driver for DVD-R/RW" only
barrier to burning DVD+R/RW media, the exact extent of universal compatibility for read/write +R/RW will probably be known within the next few days or weeks when the New G5 PowerMacs are released, and the SuperDrives in them are taken for a test "drive" and "burn".
Apple is rumored (makes sense) to be installing 8x DVD burning Superdrives[/b] manufactured by
Pioneer, notably models DVR-107 or DVR-A07, which have been generally available since the beginning of 2004, with prices dropping from $229 list to $169 street (no box, no software, no nothing, just a bare drive).
Another incentive for you to quickly move up to
8x DVD Write speed with a new Pioneer dual format drive is
PIONEER's $30 Mail-in Rebate which
expires March 31, 2004.
(Although the COUPON is not posted on Pioneer's site, several "Pioneer favored" retailers have posted the coupon for download on their own site)
Look for the words
$30 Pioneer mail-in rebate coupon!! VideoGuys.com on the site; Fry's Electronics and other retailers who are listed on Pioneer's site, have the coupons at the store check-out.
If you buy the qualifying boxed 8x DVD drive, look for a white sticker with the Serial Number stuck on the bottom of the Box, you will need that and the UPC bar code, and the Rebate Coupon, and ORIGINAL Purchase Receipt dated on or before March 31, 2004. The Pioneer box looks like this:
On Tuesday March 23rd, 2004 (or, shortly thereafter),
Apple is expected to announce the availability of NEW 8x blank Apple DVD media (probably DVD-R only) at a 5-pack price of between $14.99 to $19.99 (USD $3 to
$4 each). 8x DVD-R blank media are already available in North America at:
http://www.meritline.com/piodata-8x-dvd-r-blank-media-dvdr-discs-disc-jewel-case.html
Older 2x
Apple DVD media have virtually disappeared from shelves, including the online
Apple, and had been going for $7.99; newer 4x
Apple DVD media continues to be generally available at $9.99 per 5-pack, or $2 each.
There is no word yet when
"dual-layer" DVD-R[DL] media will be available or which consumer drives are capable of burning the one sided disks for a total of 8.5GB instead of only 4.7GB. Two-sided, single-layer discs are available for a total of 9.4 GB on one disc. However, since October 2003, Pioneer has been demonstrating Dual-Layer burning technology using its own 4x DVD burning DVR-A06 (DVR-106) with only a
"firmware change".
(C) G5 rev.A's, which should all have 4x DVD writing DVR-106 or DVR-A06 SuperDrives installed, should be able to read DVD+R/RW, and MAY be able to WRITE to these blank media as of the 10.3.3, which recently supplied my 8X Pioneer DVR-A07 drive with its very own,
brand new Apple DRIVER - something we did not have ("unsupported") at time of purchase in mid-February. Firmware is still 1.03; PCs need 1.10.
(D) Recommend BRAND and, how about prices?
Although generally
expensive, Verbatim is pretty much accepted as the best you can buy. It looks like good 8X DVD-R media will be available at $3.99 each, or $19.99 for a 5-pack. Buy enough volume, $3.39 ea.
Many of the larger sites actually list BRAND compatibility with
Mac or PC drives.
For
Apple PowerMacs:
Ritek, ACCU, Memorex,
Apple and
PioData (which appears to be
Pioneers own brand but made by Taiyo-Yuden Company of Japan, just nobody says so).
UNITED KINGDOM sources of DVD/CD-R/RW blank media are:
(see downloadable lists attached below for USA, CANADA, UK and BELGIUM)
BIG Pockets UK
BlankDisk Shop
CDr Media UK
CDr Direct UK
LynxDV
Nexus22
Blank Media Market
SpotOn UK
3000 rpm