Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

JohnMaldaner

macrumors regular
Original poster
Sep 19, 2016
112
39
Kentucky
I have a late-2012 iMac. My current external (a LaCie model) is not large enough. It’s time to upgrade. To be used with Time Machine. Looking for something in the range of 2-4 Tb. I don’t use my Mac for gaming. This drive is for backup purposes only. I’ve read reviews until I’m blurry-eyed. Then, I go to Amazon and read horror stories there on the supposedly highest rated drives. So, what have folks here been happy with?
 
a second vote for the WD (I have 4 - they all work great)

I find Amazon the best for feedback - IMHO - they have 10 x more reviews - hard to beat thousands of reviews ?

wd on amazon.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnMaldaner
Thank you both!

Does this include software to format for a Mac, or is there an easy way to do that? (Apple Disc Utility?)
 
The price difference between a 2TB and a 6TB that's on sale is almost nothing so I'd go with the higher capacity.

You really don't have to worry much about speed because whether it takes Time Machine 4 minutes or 5 minutes to back up your recent work isn't an issue.

I don't see any great deals right now, but with Black Friday coming up you'll see the lowest prices of the year then.

For reference, I found a Seagate 4TB USB 3.0 for $70 last month. The sale is expired, but that will give you a starting point.

Amazon reviews are almost worthless because rarely do people review their products 5 years after they bought them. And for a hard drive all you really care about is reliability over many years.

I went with HGST drives after reading reliability reports from BackBlaze here (look for AFR rates below 2% in the lifetime hard drive stats): https://bit.ly/2o2glud but you'll pay a premium for those. I would not be afraid to buy a Seagate, HGST, or Toshiba. Western Digital go on sale for cheap but avoid that 6TB one with a high AFR rate.
[automerge]1571581178[/automerge]
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JohnMaldaner
a second vote for the WD (I have 4 - they all work great)

I find Amazon the best for feedback - IMHO - they have 10 x more reviews - hard to beat thousands of reviews ?

View attachment 870902

I have 2 of the 4GB. They are pretty good but they are USB 3.0 and are okay in speed wise. I finally replaced mine with a Fledging MvNe case and a Silicon Power 2TB NVMe. I will use the WD Elements for long term backups.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnMaldaner
For desktop drives (which have a power adapter and need to be plugged into the wall): G-Drive are very good, and also Seagate. These are platter/spinner drives, and come in much higher capacity than portable/mobile drives, which are bus-driven (they just depend upon the computer's power).

I use Samsung's external SSDs, the T5, and also HGST/G-Drive mobile external SSDs for many of my current backing up and supplemental drives needs, and then reserve a few older external spinner drives for archival drive purposes. I have two 8 TB Seagate desktop external drives on the workstation now that handle archival storage and also regular backups. One really needs more than just one backup drive; the general "rule" is three: one on-site for current backup, a duplicate of that on-site and then a third somewhere off-site. My safe deposit box serves as the repository for safekeeping of my data (because of their small physical size, external SSDs work very nicely and fit into the box without any problem).

I don't use Time Machine so that is not an issue for me, but if I did, I would choose a larger-capacity desktop external drive, especially since your iMac is not a mobile machine, it's not going anywhere. G-Drives come already formatted for the Mac. Other drives come formatted for use with both Macs and PCs, but it is simply a matter of at the first use, opening up Disk Utility and formatting the drive there to your preferences (APFS is what is optimized for the more recent versions of MacOS, and it is also optimized for SSDs as opposed to spinner drives.).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JohnMaldaner
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.