I was looking at alternatives before buying the TC. At that time I was also in need of a new WiFi router. Reasons I went for the TC:
- one device combines router and backup, i.e. less cables, less stuff standing around, and it even looks nice
- a/c WiFi
- it is very quiet
A few weeks before I spent a night sleeping in a friends living room, which also had the WiFi routers and NAS backup device. The HDD noise was quite noticeable, and of course a mess of cables and blinking lights was everywhere. I also found that a/c routers are still somewhat expensive, so there wouldn't be much savings from going for an alternative. Finally the TC might be more energy efficient, but I'm not sure about that. But this is a device that runs 24/7, so a few more watts/hour can add up to quite a bit of money over the year.