Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Scarlet Fever

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Jul 22, 2005
3,262
0
Bookshop!
When i selected a playlist on my 10GB 3G iPod, the hard drive spun up, and it made a noise as if something was bent somewhere it shouldn't be. I replaced the battery recently, and i dont think i did a great job at it, but i wouldn't have thought i did anything to the HDD. It was running fine a few days ago, like it isnt something which has happened straight after i replaced the battery. Anyone have any ideas what is going on? If it is dead, i will be buying a new one very soon; i can't live without MyPod!
 
I believe my iPod makes the same noise yours does. I kept my 3G 15GB iPod in perfect condition, scratch-free, you get the idea, until a book fell on it in my bag. I removed the iPod from its case, and noticed a dent in the metal on the back, and also the metal was separated from the side of the iPod. Very disappointed, I turned it on, only to find it turned on and seemed like all was fine. I then turned it off, and very angry left it alone for a day. When i attempted to turn it on again, the hard drive made a huge whining noise and has not worked since. I agree, it stinks not having your iPod, but luckily I have a mini as a backup, although it does not hold my whole library. Best of luck to you.
 
so its the hard drive gone. Next question, can i just throw laptop harddrives into it? Or is there a specific size for iPod HDDs? I really like it, it has done me very well (up until now!)
Thanks for the help
 
A notebook hard drive is classed at 2.5" whereas the iPod uses 1.8" hard drives. They're not easy to find and replacing the hard drive is difficult. I guess it's worth a try although a new iPod might be cheaper and easier in the long run. :)
 
mad jew is correct. You can get some good money for a broken iPod on eBay. I usually buy them from there for spare parts for repairs. I just sold a broken iPod (bad hard drive) for $70US.
 
Sorry Scarlet... just engrave RIP on your broken iPod and cut your losses.

By doing so, u might get a better price on eBay too. :)

i agree with madjew... and the other... its probably more expensive to replace the hardrive. You're better off with a new nano or the new iPod :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.