IGg naked, Is this holster any good for the 4S?

[tunerX]

I have been looking at this holster and would like any feedback from people who are familiar with it.

http://www.handhelditems.com/holster-case-with-clip-iphone-fits-naked-iphone-only-p-157132.html

I like the J-clip, it seems like it would not slip off of my pocket. I am wondering about the durability and the ease of snapping it in and out (properly) with only one hand.

 

[rgctx]

I have been looking at this holster and would like any feedback from people who are familiar with it.

http://www.handhelditems.com/holster-case-with-clip-iphone-fits-naked-iphone-only-p-157132.html

I like the J-clip, it seems like it would not slip off of my pocket. I am wondering about the durability and the ease of snapping it in and out (properly) with only one hand.

I used that one and the one that you can use with the bumper and they both work fine. You can find that one your looking at on ebay for way cheaper (i think they ship from hong kong though), i have clipped my phone on the visor for many months using a holster simular to that and never had any issues. The only issue i have found is that the felt that is glued onto the holster to protect your screen "shreads" alot, (like a cat lol) so if you have a white iphone you will always see little black felt on it.