Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

crazytrain

macrumors member
Original poster
Sep 9, 2009
78
92
Just bought a MacBook Air M1 and decided to trade in my 2015 MacBook Pro - the battery was only lasting about 2 hours so I knew it wasn't great, but I couldn't see any signs of warping so I went ahead with the trade-in. They were offering £310 which I thought was reasonable. Anyway, just got a call from Apple guy who said, we've checked it and the battery is swollen - the new trade in value is zero!! Did I want to accept that - well clearly, no so I asked him to return it to me. I asked how much a replacement battery was and was told he didn't know. I then asked why the value was zero - he said that typically swollen battery = machine doesn't work. I told him it was working perfectly fine when I sent it to them, just that the battery only lasted 2 hours. He then said he would check back with his colleagues and see what they could do.

To say the least, I didn't hold out much hope, but literally 10 minutes after getting off the phone, I get an email saying that the value has changed but they cannot send it back to me due to government restrictions, so they'll give me the full £310!!

Great outcome as far as I'm concerned, but what if I had just accepted the 'its worth nothing' mantra and let them just keep it and recycle it...??
 
  • Like
Reactions: cmamb
If you mailed in a trade-in, Phobio is the company that takes care of it, unless it is different overseas.

Saying your trade-in value was zero is typical Phobio rhetoric and just an attempt to try and take advantage of you for their own good.

Glad you got your money. In the future, do the trade-in in store. That way, you get the quote you saw right away.
 
The OP is in the UK: ISTR the UK recycler is Brightstar, and I don't think they have the same bad reputation as Phobio. I didn't have any problems with them when I traded in my old MacBook (though of course that doesn't mean there haven't been.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
Glad you got your money. In the future, do the trade-in in store. That way, you get the quote you saw right away.
Didn't even know you could do the trade-in in store, thanks for the tip, but hopefully won't be doing it again for a few years at least 😀
 
Didn't even know you could do the trade-in in store, thanks for the tip, but hopefully won't be doing it again for a few years at least 😀
Yeah, here in the USA at least, often times I'm given the option to trade in store and that goes direct to Apple - they handle it as far as I'm aware. Anything that you mail in, here in USA is Phobio (which I've had good luck with them but I've done my homework/took tons of photos/etc).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Weaselboy
Nice to see you received the original offer.

Prior to Covid, I used to perform my trade-ins at an Apple shop (Lenox Mall, Atlanta). Just made things easier, even more so if I was purchasing something there and then...
 
Yeah, here in the USA at least, often times I'm given the option to trade in store and that goes direct to Apple
Yeah... I think that is fairly new like the last couple years. I recall when I bought a 2018 MBP they would not take my trade in store. They only did iPhones and I think iPads.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
I sent my MacBook Pro 2018 in which according to DPD they received it last Friday at 11am . I have heard nothing back as it does say takes 2 days .
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.