Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Samtb

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Jan 6, 2013
1,508
34
What’s a bigger upgrade - iPad Air to iPad Pro 10.5 or iPhone 6s to iPhone X?
 
Overall they are all running the same iOS. iPhone you are just gaining wireless charging, a faster phone, and loosing touch i.d. but gaining face i.d. The iPad has a faster processor and sharper screen.

Everything is relative to how you use your iPad and iPhone. If you own a MacBook, think about when you upgrade. Which is more important? Processing or Added features (i.e. Touch Bar, ports Touch iD,etc)
 
Overall they are all running the same iOS. iPhone you are just gaining wireless charging, a faster phone, and loosing touch i.d. but gaining face i.d. The iPad has a faster processor and sharper screen.

Everything is relative to how you use your iPad and iPhone. If you own a MacBook, think about when you upgrade. Which is more important? Processing or Added features (i.e. Touch Bar, ports Touch iD,etc)
I use iPhone the most. Ipad I mainly use for watching videos and movies or doing quick web browsing. Lack of multitasking and lagging on the iPad Air does annoy me sometimes, which the iPad Pro would resolve, but I guess iPad isn’t really made for productivity anyway and the MacBook Pro sorts that out. Same with google drive. I don’t find that particularly easy to use on iPad but I guess the pro won’t really sort that out. It might make it faster but it’s still a mobile interface.
 
The iPad Pro will definitely be a big boost. A lot of people have been using iPads for production before and now with the iPad Pro and a faster processor its even more powerful. At times I feel like that iPad Pro is very close to a MacBook Pro. Importing RAW camera files to Photoshop using my camera app or with an adapter, creating music, etc

The thing that Apple got right, which has always been there, is how everything connects. You work on your iPad, then move it to the MacBook. Its an easy transition. So your question...the iPad Pro would be the best upgrade.
 
Everything is relative to how you use your iPad and iPhone. If you own a MacBook, think about when you upgrade. Which is more important? Processing or Added features (i.e. Touch Bar, ports Touch iD,etc)

I agree with and endorse this statement.

but I guess iPad isn’t really made for productivity anyway
It might make it faster but it’s still a mobile interface.

Let's... just not go there. If you don't want to use your iPad for productivity, that's fine but don't project your own use (or lack thereof) on the device. The iPad IS a productivity tool, it's just not the right tool for everybody. End of story.

If you're more comfortable on your Macbook than the iPad for "productivity", then your better bet is the iPhone upgrade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: akash.nu
I agree with and endorse this statement.




Let's... just not go there. If you don't want to use your iPad for productivity, that's fine but don't project your own use (or lack thereof) on the device. The iPad IS a productivity tool, it's just not the right tool for everybody. End of story.

If you're more comfortable on your Macbook than the iPad for "productivity", then your better bet is the iPhone upgrade.
It’s still a difficult choice. The iPad pro would be fast and less annoying. But the iPhone X has a better camera and the latest tech.
 
It’s still a difficult choice. The iPad pro would be fast and less annoying. But the iPhone X has a better camera and the latest tech.

I think iPhone upgrade will be better for you given your attitude towards iPads in general.
 
I think iPhone upgrade will be better for you given your attitude towards iPads in general.
I still like iPad. The iPad Air is just annoying now because it’s become laggy and cant multitask.
 
Support for Pencil and better screen. Of course also more powerful but you won’t really need that horsepower with your usage.
What would the extra horsepower be useful for? Would it be video editing, 3D design etc?

I do occasionally use iPad for docs/slides/sheets etc and also sharing/emailing things from google drive.
 
What would the extra horsepower be useful for? Would it be video editing, 3D design etc?

I do occasionally use iPad for docs/slides/sheets etc and also sharing/emailing things from google drive.

Yes mostly video and photo editing, graphics design and drawings.

For your usage iPad 2017 is perfect . I do all that all day everyday. Get a small wireless keyboard if you’re into typing a lot and you’ll be set.
 
Yes mostly video and photo editing, graphics design and drawings.

For your usage iPad 2017 is perfect . I do all that all day everyday. Get a small wireless keyboard if you’re into typing a lot and you’ll be set.
Can it handle Skype video/voice calls and drive at the same time?
[doublepost=1512647280][/doublepost]
Can it handle Skype video/voice calls and drive at the same time?
I am quite tempted by iPhone X though for the new tech, bigger screen and better camera and better battery life.
[doublepost=1512648140][/doublepost]
Can it handle Skype video/voice calls and drive at the same time?
[doublepost=1512647280][/doublepost]
I am quite tempted by iPhone X though for the new tech, bigger screen and better camera and better battery life.
The battery life on the 6s is terrible with my usage. iPad still lasts probably due to higher battery.
 
Can it handle Skype video/voice calls and drive at the same time?

With ease. In fact being on a video call while working is a bliss on iPad with iOS 11 and the new multi window feature.

I am quite tempted by iPhone X though for the new tech, bigger screen and better camera and better battery life.

The price difference between the pro models and the iPad 2017 is huge. You could potentially have budget to upgrade both.

The battery life on the 6s is terrible with my usage. iPad still lasts probably due to higher battery.

The X lasts longer than average non plus model iPhones for sure. But no iPhone can ever match the battery life of an iPad. Really depends on your usage and requirements to be honest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rui no onna
I connected my iPad pro to my wireless speaker and compared the sound to my iPhone 5SE. The sound was more powerful with the iPad. Speakers on the the iPad Pro are louder than the 2017 iPad because they have more speakers. You can get a 64GB iPad Pro for $500. The iPad Pro has faster chip. Don't forget that. iPhone X screen goes out to the edge. Some apps aren't utilizing that full screen. Camera? eheh? I can take decent photos with my iPhone. Post editing, there are a some apps that will give you that look. For me it's not worth the upgrade.

Like akash.nu said you could probably budget both.


If Microcenter isn't in your area. You can get Bet Buy to price match.

http://www.microcenter.com/product/480548/105-inch_iPad_Pro_Wi-Fi_64GB_-_Space_Gray
 
With ease. In fact being on a video call while working is a bliss on iPad with iOS 11 and the new multi window feature.



The price difference between the pro models and the iPad 2017 is huge. You could potentially have budget to upgrade both.



The X lasts longer than average non plus model iPhones for sure. But no iPhone can ever match the battery life of an iPad. Really depends on your usage and requirements to be honest.
I sometimes tether my iPad to iPhone as well which really sucks power out of the iPhone. I’d do it more often if it didn’t take so much power or if I could share data between my iPad and iPhone but my carrier doesn’t let me do that.
 
Is iPhone 6s to iPhone X a bigger upgrade than iPad Air to iPad Pro 10.5?
 
Ipad Air to Ipad Pro 10.5 is a far larger upgrade.

4x amount of RAM, 120hz screen, quad speakers, iPhone 7 cameras. Not to mention going from an A7 processor to the A10x is a huge jump.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TechFann
Is iPhone 6s to iPhone X a bigger upgrade than iPad Air to iPad Pro 10.5?

No. If you don’t play games or are an instagrammer for a living, most apps like safari, gmail, Facebook etc won’t be better on the iPhone X. Phones have reached the point of diminishing returns. Battery life will be better but get a battery replacement and a different case for you 6s and it will fell like a new phone.

I had an iPad 3 which was painfully slow to the point that I didn’t want to use it. In 2 months I have used my 10.5 more than I did my iPad 3 during the 24 months before I traded it in. The loud speakers are so good that I rarely pair the iPad with my blunt tooth kitchen speaker, split screen is god sent and picture in picture is used frequently.

It’s been HUGE upgrade to the point that I now want to grab the iPad more often than the MacBook.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TechFann
No. If you don’t play games or are an instagrammer for a living, most apps like safari, gmail, Facebook etc won’t be better on the iPhone X. Phones have reached the point of diminishing returns. Battery life will be better but get a battery replacement and a different case for you 6s and it will fell like a new phone.

I had an iPad 3 which was painfully slow to the point that I didn’t want to use it. In 2 months I have used my 10.5 more than I did my iPad 3 during the 24 months before I traded it in. The loud speakers are so good that I rarely pair the iPad with my blunt tooth kitchen speaker, split screen is god sent and picture in picture is used frequently.

It’s been HUGE upgrade to the point that I now want to grab the iPad more often than the MacBook.
But compared to an iPad Air would an iPad Pro 10.5 be much of an upgrade?

I’m also pondering whether the iPhone upgrade is better given that my 6s battery life is now terrible, the x has a bigger screen and better camera. The air isn’t too bad with speed and battery life is ok.
 
Last edited:
I use iPhone the most. Ipad I mainly use for watching videos and movies or doing quick web browsing. Lack of multitasking and lagging on the iPad Air does annoy me sometimes, which the iPad Pro would resolve, but I guess iPad isn’t really made for productivity anyway and the MacBook Pro sorts that out. Same with google drive. I don’t find that particularly easy to use on iPad but I guess the pro won’t really sort that out. It might make it faster but it’s still a mobile interface.

Sounds like you already made your decision: iPhone X.
 
But compared to an iPad Air would an iPad Pro 10.5 be much of an upgrade?

I’m also pondering whether the iPhone upgrade is better given that my 6s battery life is now terrible, the x has a bigger screen and better camera. The air isn’t too bad with speed and battery life is ok.

Yes the Pro is still a big upgrade from the Air. But if you are ok with the speed then stick with the Air until you are fed up and get the X. Or get a battery replacement for your 6s for little money and ponder a bit longer.
 
If I were you, I would save some money and just get the 2017 iPad. Then use that saved money to get the 2018 iPhone next year. The X is not worth the early adopter cost imo. By 2018, even the regular iPhone will sport the same features as the X, and you will get it for less.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rui no onna
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.