Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iphone 3G in Hong Kong really network unlocked?

M

msantoso

macrumors member
Original poster
Apr 22, 2008
36
0
read somewhere in tuaw that iphone 3G in Hong Kong, Italy and one more country available totally network unlocked, but will a firmware upgrade lock it? anyone using it yet?

maybe later might be possible to create ipsw dump file from this unlocked phone for use w/ locked phone?

i really like some apps like the remote app, facebook, bloomberg, just purchased enigmo yesterday, boxoffice w/ location support, ebay, and the coming wordpress app is going to make this phone even better. oh and vnc is now available too.
 
msantoso said:
read somewhere in tuaw that iphone 3G in Hong Kong, Italy and one more country available totally network unlocked, but will a firmware upgrade lock it? anyone using it yet?

maybe later might be possible to create ipsw dump file from this unlocked phone for use w/ locked phone?

i really like some apps like the remote app, facebook, bloomberg, just purchased enigmo yesterday, boxoffice w/ location support, ebay, and the coming wordpress app is going to make this phone even better. oh and vnc is now available too.
Click to expand...
Apple has a list of countries that are not required to have locked phones.
 
Here is a screenshot from my iPhone on HK Smartone-Vodafone network, instead of 3HK which is the only authorized HK operator currently. I have managed to update from 345 to 347 firmware without any problems lock-wise. I can still use Smartone sim card.

I personally never tried using sim card from other countries but there are many people from China and Macau buying iPhones 3G from HK. I think this indicates that HK iPhones 3G is really unlocked.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0001.png
    IMG_0001.png
    40.5 KB · Views: 103
i saw in apple document (given in this thread) that in HK there's 2 providers selling iphone 3g, that is 3 and Vodafone.

when you upgrade from 345 to 347, does it need activation? or it's activated? how do you do the upgrade? direct from iTunes Update button?

some HK site says that it still needs to subscribe to 2 years contract to buy the unlocked phone
 
watergun said:
Here is a screenshot from my iPhone on HK Smartone-Vodafone network, instead of 3HK which is the only authorized HK operator currently. I have managed to update from 345 to 347 firmware without any problems lock-wise. I can still use Smartone sim card.

I personally never tried using sim card from other countries but there are many people from China and Macau buying iPhones 3G from HK. I think this indicates that HK iPhones 3G is really unlocked.
Click to expand...
There was a thread somewhere that these phones are locked by country. So you can't actually use sim cards from other countries. How? I don't know.
 
the statement below is taken from iphone.three.com.hk FAQ Section

Will standalone iPhone 3G handset be available for sale?

No. The iPhone 3G needs to go with a series of data-centric tariff plan in order to perform its best. 3 Hong Kong has tailor-made a series of data tariff plans, coupled with unique contents and applications, allowing 3G users to fully indulge in the mobile Internet world.
Click to expand...
 
ubersalad said:
There was a thread somewhere that these phones are locked by country. So you can't actually use sim cards from other countries. How? I don't know.
Click to expand...

Has anyone been able to confirm this? Are Hong Kong iPhones country locked or not?
 
The strange thing about Apples official list is that it list the belgium Mobistar iPhone as operator locked while people have confirmed that it indeed is not and works on networks outside of the country.

Puzzling.

Also, I think some form of hardware difference makes the unlocked iPhones unlocked. How else would they know if they should be unlocked when they are firmware restored?
 
The iPhone 3G in Hong Kong should be unlocked. It works with 2 different carriers' sim cards I tried. I'll be visiting Canada next week so I'll definitely test out Rogers/Fido sim card too. I'll let you know by then
 
hardware differences? i think this is highly unlikely? maybe by serial number or IMEI.. or so..
 
zainjetha said:
hardware differences? i think this is highly unlikely? maybe by serial number or IMEI.. or so..
Click to expand...

That is what I mean, I think the hardware difference is the part number. Each country has its own group of part numbers. You can look them up here.

http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1937

But the list either has some confirmed errors or Apple is just straight face lying about some of the facts.

I think maybe iTunes looks at your iPhones, part number, IMEI, whatever unique hardware unchangeable marker of an unactivated iPhone hooked up to it and then maybe takes the correct action, such as unlocking and activating the so called unlocked ones.
 
kamiboy said:
That is what I mean, I think the hardware difference is the part number. Each country has its own group of part numbers. You can look them up here.

http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1937

But the list either has some confirmed errors or Apple is just straight face lying about some of the facts.

I think maybe iTunes looks at your iPhones, part number, IMEI, whatever unique hardware unchangeable marker of an unactivated iPhone hooked up to it and then maybe takes the correct action, such as unlocking and activating the so called unlocked ones.
Click to expand...

This makes much sense. I agree with your conclusion.

I had been wondering about this myself. It seems like a reasonable approach to unlocking a US (or other locked) iPhone would be to find a way to cease control of the communications between the iPhone and iTunes and fake the part number/IMEI/whatever. I have no idea what that would entail, but it would give you the huge advantage of not having to jailbreak the phone and not having some hacked software or hacked SIM piggyback. In effect it would be a completely legit iPhone that iTunes thought was from a different country.
 
mkoesel said:
This makes much sense. I agree with your conclusion.

I had been wondering about this myself. It seems like a reasonable approach to unlocking a US (or other locked) iPhone would be to find a way to cease control of the communications between the iPhone and iTunes and fake the part number/IMEI/whatever. I have no idea what that would entail, but it would give you the huge advantage of not having to jailbreak the phone and not having some hacked software or hacked SIM piggyback. In effect it would be a completely legit iPhone that iTunes thought was from a different country.
Click to expand...

Yes, ever since I found out about legit unlocked iPhone back at the 1st gen iPhone I thought that it would be just a matter of time before the so called hackers would be able to copy the legit unlock process and would put an end to all the ugly software modification hacks. But here we are months later and nothing, some people just don't care about jail breaking their iPhone and all they want is a simple unlock and activation without any ugly hacks, but the hacker community has ignored that.
 
kamiboy said:
Yes, ever since I found out about legit unlocked iPhone back at the 1st gen iPhone I thought that it would be just a matter of time before the so called hackers would be able to copy the legit unlock process and would put an end to all the ugly software modification hacks. But here we are months later and nothing, some people just don't care about jail breaking their iPhone and all they want is a simple unlock and activation without any ugly hacks, but the hacker community has ignored that.
Click to expand...
I am sure if unlocking the phone is as easy as a text message from your carrier, these groups won't bother with releasing their own custom firmware.
 
To hell with the hackers soon i'll be getting a legit unlocked 3G and will never look back.
 
kanon14 said:
The iPhone 3G in Hong Kong should be unlocked. It works with 2 different carriers' sim cards I tried. I'll be visiting Canada next week so I'll definitely test out Rogers/Fido sim card too. I'll let you know by then
Click to expand...

hey kanon, let us know if the SIM card from another country works for you :)
Thanks!
 
Uny update

I'm going to get an unlocked iPhone 3G from HK. so 2 Questions.
1. did your HK phone work in Canada with a Canadian SIM?
2. when it's "Activated", it's not then locked to that Network is it? You can freely switch Networks SIM cards?
3. Is activation required again when you switch carrier's SIM cards?

OK 3, make that 3 questions...

I like to get prepaid Sim cards when I travel. And reactivation might not be possible in remote areas of Laos, for example. (Tango Lao had free international SMS messaging and very cheap international calls when I was there 2 years ago. All for just a $5 prepaid sim, including $5 worth of calls - almost an hour of international calls. Amazing deal)

Thanks
Scott
 
scottdk said:
I'm going to get an unlocked iPhone 3G from HK. so 2 Questions.
1. did your HK phone work in Canada with a Canadian SIM?
2. when it's "Activated", it's not then locked to that Network is it? You can freely switch Networks SIM cards?
3. Is activation required again when you switch carrier's SIM cards?

OK 3, make that 3 questions...

I like to get prepaid Sim cards when I travel. And reactivation might not be possible in remote areas of Laos, for example. (Tango Lao had free international SMS messaging and very cheap international calls when I was there 2 years ago. All for just a $5 prepaid sim, including $5 worth of calls - almost an hour of international calls. Amazing deal)

Thanks
Scott
Click to expand...
1. I think so
2. yes, I use Indonesian sim card for the iphone that I got from hongkong
3. The activation is only plugging in to the itunes (at least for me when I put Indonesian sim card)
and for sure I can upgrade the firmware and still use the Indonesian sim card withouth unlocking it
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back