Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

puma1552

Suspended
Original poster
Nov 20, 2008
5,559
1,948
I ordered two items from Peel. Their "silver" case (which is really a translucent frost) and their white edge-to-edge glass screen protector for my silver iPhone 8. I installed both today.

Screen Protector:

The packaging was nice and included the usual pack-ins - microfiber cloth, alcohol wipe, dust sticker, instructions, and screen protector.

My first impression of the screen protector is that it's probably the best thing since Cinder, which I had on my 6 (albeit in black). I can't confirm, but it looks to be more like 0.2mm thick like the Cinder and not 0.3mm thick like a lot of others out there. Did not reach out to Peel to ask, their site doesn't specify.

The edges appear to be rounded/3D/molded to the phone unlike a lot of the cheaper 2/2.5D glass ones. Much like Cinder. Coverage is great. Much like Cinder.

One thing I did notice is the white is not an absolute perfect match to the phone's white bezel. It is *very* close (a tad softer in color tone) but you cannot tell at all when it's on, even compared to the exposed home button, so this is a non-issue. Can't speak for the Cinder as mine was black.

The edge around the home button is fine, but it is not as softly rounded as the Cinder was. Touch ID still works fine. On that note, so does 3D touch.

The installation went fine, I got one hair under there but I was able to lift up the corner and grab it with a piece of tape. Alignment is perfect and was actually pretty easy - you can basically set it down on the phone and move it a little to align it and THEN press down to adhere it - you don't need to worry about it sticking in the first position where it touches the screen. Clarity and feel are like there's nothing on the screen.

I have one potential criticism: I feel a bit like I'm looking through a window when the screen is on, and I think it's because - if I recall from before I put it on, and like how my white SE is - there's actually supposed to be a tiny black border around the active part of the screen, and this covers it. In fact I believe it covers a sliver of your active screen on the sides as well, but not enough to interfere with any content. It is a little odd having white bezel immediately adjacent to your content without that minor black line around the screen - you can tilt your phone to the side and basically see the black screen outline that is covered up. A little disappointing but I'll get used to it though. I can't speak for if my old Cinder suffered from this or not, as that one was black on a black phone so I would not have noticed anyway. I don't think it did though.

All in all the screen protector gets 4.5/5 stars. Highly recommended as a Cinder alternative since Cupert Technology is what it is. Would bypass the Cinder and go straight to the Peel in the future.

Case:

Packaging was nice and simple. The case is made of PP plastic according to Peel, which I assume means Polypropylene. I come from a world of rigid polycarbonate clear cases, so there's a little adjustment here. Out of the box, if I'm totally honest, it is pretty flimsy/cheap feeling. It's not rubbery, it's definitely plastic, but it's flimsy as you'd expect given the 0.35mm thickness and it doesn't look particularly immaculately formed - the phone is going to do that for you once you install it. The color is nice, but despite being a matte/translucent case it doesn't really afford any extra grip which I found surprising.

Once on the phone, it seems much nicer. It's tight to the phone like a skin, feels like nothing is there, and the buttons are flush with the case. All of the cutouts are precise except the camera cutout - the lip is covered, but there is a little excess material on the bottom edge but it does not affect camera function. Otherwise the fit of the case is excellent and it wraps right to the upper edge of the aluminum frame of the phone, no more no less. It's complimented very well with the screen protector they sell.

Phone shows through nicely and the case does have a nice feel to it in the case. Wireless charging with the Belkin pad from Apple works fine.

I have a few potential criticisms: Peel advertises that this case protects against scratches and light bumps. Nobody is expecting this to save your phone in a real drop, but to be honest I have my doubts about even bumps like a 2-3" drop onto the table or bumping the corner of the phone into a desk. I'm not sure it really inspires confidence for anything at all except scratch protection for laying it on hard surfaces.

Another criticism is I'm just not sure how long the case will last or if it will stretch out. If it does, that'll be too bad but if it keeps its current form it will be great.

The last criticism is probably just paranoia - given the softness of the glass back on the phone, I'm worried that just putting the phone in and out of the case will potentially scratch the glass or leave micro-scratches in the oleophobic coating on the phone. I guess time will tell.

Case gets 4/5 stars. At least initially, I am recommending this as a great case for people who hate cases and are still very careful but don't want to have to worry about setting their phone on a napkin or something when they go out.

Overall:

Happy with both purchases, phone feels and looks good and I would buy both again at this time.

Now for some pics:

36792231133_e485e695a1_b.jpg


36792232543_1ab2ac1d96_b.jpg


36792233843_14cedcf1ac_b.jpg


36792235943_2929164a0c_b.jpg


36792239523_ed023d9d90_b.jpg


37414565456_7aafba78fd_b.jpg


37414566746_e9e5d27ffd_b.jpg


37414568296_0739ff3ff6_b.jpg


37431077752_4642491691_b.jpg


37431079652_19aed32a59_b.jpg


37204523490_2bb2754263_b.jpg
 
Last edited:
I purchased the Jet Black case for the iPhone 7 Plus and within a month, it was so dull and scratched up, I swore off buying the brand any more.
 
It looks great but I guarantee you that over time you’re gonna have one scratched up finishing at the back of your iPhone. One and only reason why I don’t use any case without a soft lining.

I hope that isn't the case but we will see. So far I've been lucky with clear polycarbonate cases but I am a bit concerned about the glass on this one. Time will tell but so far I'm actually really loving the Peel case/protector. One thing that's nice about the silver case is that it doesn't scratch at all like a polycarbonate/jet case.
 
Now spent over 30 minutes trying to remove the case with ZERO success.

Except I did scratch the hell out of the case in the process:

37506721112_76eec1405a_b.jpg


EDIT: Eventually got it off by the top corners, but the case is basically beat to hell at this point and won't be going back on the phone. I'm an ex-AirJacket user and I never had problems taking that one on and off when everyone else did. On the plus side, zero damage or microabrasions on the phone or back glass whatsoever after the better part of a week's worth of normal use which is what I really wanted to know and is the reason I took it off.

I reached out to Peel to show them the pic so I'll see what they say. If they were to send me another case free, then I would be more than happy to use it and stick it on the phone once and leave it there permanently. Until then I guess it's off to Apple to grab a silicone one. :\
 
Last edited:
I have the Tozo case, which is the exact same case except way cheaper. I am not sure if the Peel fits tighter, but I have no issues removing my Tozo case. I just use my thumb on one of the bottom corners and push applying pressure from front to back of device and it comes right off.
 
now in a black silicone apple case, actually works great with the peel protector. hugs over the edges of it for complete protection.
 
For anyone still following...

I received my replacement today after waiting 1+ week.

Unfortunately, within 10 minutes, it was in the trash. Absolutely would not go ON the phone. The upper non-camera corner wasn't even close to being even remotely able to slide up over the corner of the phone, not a chance. Tried to install it 10 different times using Peel's recommended way (bottom corners first, followed by top corners) and even tried putting it in sideways with the volume button side first.

Ultimately I ended up compressing the upper corner too much and deforming it and getting a big ugly white crease in the plastic. Into the trash it went which was super disappointing.

I did reach out to Peel again so I'll see what they say, I didn't say if I wanted another case or a refund, just described the experience so I'll see if they offer anything.
 
So...bye bye Apple Silicone cases. Peel offered to give me a refund or send me another free case, but that it would take some time as they were tweaking the fit for the new batch. I opted to give the case one more shot.

The new case arrived today and it went on no problems! Peel's customer service is fantastic. I liked my Apple silicone cases, but this Peel case is sublime. Love Peel's service. Highly recommended.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.