Is Photoshop Elements marginalized by iPhoto 5?

[Diomedes]

I haven't explored all of iPhoto 5's features, but do its new features reduce the value of Photoshop Elements?

 

[jsw]

While there's more you can do in iP5 than in iP4, PE3 is an excellent upgrade to PE2, and my personal opinion is that PE3 is still very much a useful utility - it is a lot more powerful than iP5. However, many users who just do garden-variety photo cleanup will find iP5 to be more than adequate and won't need PE3.

 

[andrewfee]

I have to agree; it's much more powerful, and (on my 20" iMac G5 at least) much faster for doing the same edits.

For the average user, iPhoto's tools will probably be enough though.

 

[JDar]

I haven't explored all of iPhoto 5's features, but do its new features reduce the value of Photoshop Elements?

Exploring all of iPhoto 5's features will take a few mintutes. Discovering and using all of Photoshop Elements 3's feature will take weeks, if not months if you are really trying.

 

[Floyd WHO]

PE still has it's place

IP5 is really nice but you couldn't beat me to give up PE