Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

oxband

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Sep 10, 2009
333
4
I do documentary film. I always save the raw cards after I transfer them into Pro Res. Is that redundant? I kind of figured it might be worth doing in case, for whatever reason, AVCHD transferring somehow in the future can be done at a higher rate and my footage therefore might look different/better than the Pro Res I have now.

That said, that's a hypothetical based on nothing.

Is it silly to save my raw cards in addition to the exported footage?
 
I save copies of all my camera cards plus make Camera Archives in FCP X, and back up twice.
 
This has been a bugbear of mine since the last days of mini-dv tape, you see the problem no one has paid any attention to...What has happened is that in 2018 we are right back in the early days of film, the medium on which we "save" the video image at point of capture is limited, unlike mini-dv tape that was cheap and lasted a long time, that is you could shoot 60 minutes and then in seconds,eject and carry on, sure the process of getting the material into the computer was slow, 1 to 1...

So someone had the idea that something faster than 1:1, would be better, which for news makes sense, but for other forms, not so much, maybe bridezilla's you need faster than 1:1:, like have the edited version done before the wedding...

Now we are screwed royally, we have RED that you can only record a couple of minutes per card, and then that takes an age to transfer, all in the name of video quality..which is important...what is important?? Image quality or transfer time???

Look codecs will change, pro res will be different in 6 months time, maybe.. Keeping multiple copies of source material will be very expensive if it is not going to reused again, what do you do? With mini-dv tapes, you basically only used the tape twice, once to record onto, and a 2nd to digitize...so you did not have to worry about too much tape use...

I don't have an answer, other than I hope one day someone wakes up and sees the iceberg ahead..I see it and all I see is disaster ahead...We as a industry are fast asleep...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.