Carrier Is this a AT&T Ripoff?

[tomsmac]

My son came off my account over a year ago.
I am not on any contract with AT&T and I have owned my phone for a couple of years.

Yet, when I continue to ask about the additional Mobile Share value iPhone charge of $40.00 I feel like I'm getting spun around in circles. Whey would they charge me an additional $40 (-15 disc) for a Mobile share when I'm not sharing any date etc...? Img attached.
Am I being ripped off?

Thank you.

 

[theshoehorn]

You're still on a mobile share plan (the 6gb one). Because you're off contract you get a $15 discount off the price of an access line.

All mobile share plans have a cost for the actual plan ($70 in this case) and each device has a cost ($40). Being on Next or no contact gets you a "discount" to that line. Hope that helps!

 

[Applejuiced]

Expensive plan for 1 line only with no device included either.

 

[Ladybug]

My bill works out to $109.84 a month on AT&T. That includes 2 lines with 3gb data with rollover. I don't think its cheap either but you have to use what works best in your area.