Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

desertman

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Jul 14, 2008
708
40
Arizona, USA
I was today at a friend's house who had recently upgraded to macOS Mohave and subscribed to iTunes Music. Since then hundreds of her audio files have disappeared. They are still listed in iTunes but have an exclamation mark next to their name and cannot be played anymore. Among them are many songs that she imported - still on her previous Mac - from her own CD collection into iTunes and also some albums that she previously had bought through iTunes.

Another strange thing is that all of her playlists don't work anymore, even when they have songs that are still on her computer.

It appears to me that these files are irrevocably gone - I cannot find them with Spotlight or with EasyFind anywhere on her hard disk. Unfortunately it is not completely clear whether these songs were previously on her hard disk or stored somehwere on Apples's iCloud servers.

My friend thinks that this happened after she subscribed to iTunes Music but she is not sure whether it possibly happened already earlier after upgrading to Mohave.

The whole story is very mysterious to me. Does anybody here have an idea what happened (and how the missing songs can possibly get recovered)? Thanks.
 
Back when Apple Music launched, this was a wide spread problem. Many people didn't even know until their AM free trial ended, then it kind of blew up.

Basically, the AM files were replacing the user created files, I think it was linked to a confusing prompt that the users selected the option to do this. IIRC, the issue was kind of fixed with an iTunes update and making it harder to accidentally replace non-Apple Music files.

It was a pretty big problem though, I have iTunes Match, but never signed up for the AM trial, and my entire library of 3K songs disappeared.

They were in iTunes, but were greyed out with an exclamation on them.

After a few weeks of trying to get them recovered by Apple Engineers, there final update to me was that I never had any Matched songs, which of course was bull crap.

Luckily I had a backup of almost ever song

BTW, if there are any iTunes purchased songs, they should be able to recover them.
[doublepost=1550628569][/doublepost]Did your friend signup for Apple Music a few years ago?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.