Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Linksys vs. Airport Extreme

Grimace

Grimace

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Feb 17, 2003
3,574
259
with Hamburglar.
Currently I have a linksys WRT54G unit (4 ethernet jacks + wireless G) hooked up.* I
never saw any reason to pay more for an Airport when other devices did the same
thing for $79.* The USB port on the airport has me hooked now.* A few questions: *

1.* Can I hook up any USB device to the airport and have all wireless notebooks be
able to use it (similar to print sharing.) *

2.* If the answer to #1 is yes, could I hook up a USB hub and have 4 USB devices
(printer, spare harddrive, etc) accessible by the computers on the network? *

3.* Given my current hardware, is it possible to add in a USB device (like a printer) to
share?* As in, a USB-ethernet jack converter??* (this may not exist)
 
carletonmusic said:
Currently I have a linksys WRT54G unit (4 ethernet jacks + wireless G) hooked up.* I
never saw any reason to pay more for an Airport when other devices did the same
thing for $79.* The USB port on the airport has me hooked now.* A few questions: *

1.* Can I hook up any USB device to the airport and have all wireless notebooks be
able to use it (similar to print sharing.) *

2.* If the answer to #1 is yes, could I hook up a USB hub and have 4 USB devices
(printer, spare harddrive, etc) accessible by the computers on the network? *

3.* Given my current hardware, is it possible to add in a USB device (like a printer) to
share?* As in, a USB-ethernet jack converter??* (this may not exist)
Click to expand...

Someones been doing some seriously thinking....well done. I am very interested to find out if you could do what's posted above. I think I am going to go rent an AE tomorrow and try this out. This has the potential to be very cool.
 
carletonmusic said:
What is the technological barrier that keeps people from networking hard external hard drives in the same manner that they would network printers?
Click to expand...
Complexity issue. Printer sharing is easy because all the technology is simple and has been out for forever. Network File Systems are weirder and have a lot more issues (a printer just needs a print queue so you can have 1000 things send things into a queue, a harddrive has read/write synchronization issues -- what if 2 things write the same file at the same time? What if one writes a file while another wants to read that file?)
 
Nikko1965 said:
Take a butcher's at http://usa.asus.com/products/communication/wireless/wl-500g/overview.htm

Seems an external drive can supported as can a webcam or printer. Nice.

Cheers,

Nick
Click to expand...

Would that also work with the Airport Extreme??

I'm guessing that networking data like that would work for drive intensive tasks like video editing. Like store imported footage on the disk, so that two different machines could access the data and just store all rendered files locally? If this is too slow, is there a way to do something like that??
 
if you navigate around the site (especially the 'internet' and 'disk' links at the bottom,) the spelling and grammar is HORRIBLE!! It almost makes me want to believe that the product or company is a hoax or scam. What major product manufacturer would have so much wrong with its website designed to sell merchandise??
 
stoid said:
Would that also work with the Airport Extreme??

I'm guessing that networking data like that would work for drive intensive tasks like video editing. Like store imported footage on the disk, so that two different machines could access the data and just store all rendered files locally? If this is too slow, is there a way to do something like that??
Click to expand...

I'm assuming that it would not be a function of AE or Apple would be all over that in its marketing. This device seems to have that capability specially built in.
 
RT Grammatically Superior M

carletonmusic said:
if you navigate around the site (especially the 'internet' and 'disk' links at the bottom,) the spelling and grammar is HORRIBLE!! It almost makes me want to believe that the product or company is a hoax or scam. What major product manufacturer would have so much wrong with its website designed to sell merchandise??
Click to expand...

I must admit it's a pretty shoddy write up although the ability to use "MSN massager" is quite a tempter. Still, their English is far better than my Chinese.

If you go to the download section you'll find a 7M PDF of the manual which should not only answer most questions but will also greatly reduce William Shakespeare's posthumous RPM.

Cheers,

Nick
 
stoid said:
Would that also work with the Airport Extreme??

I'm guessing that networking data like that would work for drive intensive tasks like video editing. Like store imported footage on the disk, so that two different machines could access the data and just store all rendered files locally? If this is too slow, is there a way to do something like that??
Click to expand...

this product exists.

but, you would hook it up via ethernet, not the usb port. MUCH faster.

but, it would be best to be on a wires 1000baseT network if you are moving a lot of data. G would not do it for you. (1000>54)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back