Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

jasnw

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Nov 15, 2013
1,076
1,140
Seattle Area (NOT! Microsoft)
I'm thinking of buying an M1 Mini from either eBay or the refurb store as a test machine while I wait (possibly forever) for Apple to release an Mx desktop machine between the current Mini and the Studio. I'd use this to replace my home server once (if) Apple does see the light, which is an Intel i7 with 16GB memory. My question is about memory needs. I'd like to go as inexpensive as possible, which means 8GB memory. I'm still not sure what memory needs are on M1 machines, so I don't know if 8GB will suffice. It's fine for a test machine, but I don't want to end up with a throttled server because of low memory. I suspect there's not a problem, because the server isn't really doing anything I'd consider memory-intensive, mostly runs some processing scripts/codes (Fortran/python stuff written by me) and handles the backup drives. I got 16GB on the current Mini because of the direction macOS (then OSX) was headed at the time (towards bloated). I'm running Big Sur on an Intel MBP with 8GB, and it does show sluggishness at times, but that's on Intel silicon and I hear rumors that the M1 platform needs less memory. I'm happy with having most storage external, so the size of the internal SSD is not a concern.

If this were a machine I'd be using face-to-face on a daily basis, I'd do 16 GB. However, for an essentially headless server that's not handling video (or heavy audio) I'm not sure that 8GB isn't enough. Thoughts?
 
I'm not sure what kind of server would it be. As for the home server only 8Gb should be enough
 
It's not running any traditional server-like software like Plex (for instance). It runs a variety of data processing and analysis codes (neither image nor audio) 24x7 to build simple graphics for a website hosted elsewhere, and CCC-based backups for various computers in the house use external HDs mounted on this computer. The current Mini is running Mavericks, mostly because I've not had a need to update it. I'm fairly sure that 8GB will be fine, but I have no personal experience with an M1 system on which to base an assessment.
 
I bought a base refurbed M1 (256/8gb) as a replacement for my 2012 i5 Mini. That mini serves as my Time Machine/iTunes server, plus other assorted tasks.

I plugged the M1 Mini into the monitor my Windows rig uses and have been completely blown away by how powerful that little dude is.

It's now my primary desktop, albeit augmented with a 2TB SSD external for storage.

I plan to actually retire the i5 mini when either:
1. That mini dies.
2. Apple releases a M1 Pro mini.

I have no doubts that the base M1 Mini will be more than adequate for the tasks you describe. But you will need more storage.
 
Not sure how your external drives are connected to your current Mini (any hubs) but it seems like I keep hearing about the Apple Silicon Macs being a bit finicky about what works. Just something to check out or be prepared to handle.
 
I bought a base refurbed M1 (256/8gb) as a replacement for my 2012 i5 Mini. That mini serves as my Time Machine/iTunes server, plus other assorted tasks.

I plugged the M1 Mini into the monitor my Windows rig uses and have been completely blown away by how powerful that little dude is.

It's now my primary desktop, albeit augmented with a 2TB SSD external for storage.

I plan to actually retire the i5 mini when either:
1. That mini dies.
2. Apple releases a M1 Pro mini.

I have no doubts that the base M1 Mini will be more than adequate for the tasks you describe. But you will need more storage.
Thanks. Sounds like what I was expecting - but hoping isn't knowing.
 
Not sure how your external drives are connected to your current Mini (any hubs) but it seems like I keep hearing about the Apple Silicon Macs being a bit finicky about what works. Just something to check out or be prepared to handle.
Thanks for the reminder. I have also heard this rumor and need to make sure my current drives and network setup will work.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.