Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Jarousin

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 4, 2020
11
5
Hi all, I need to pickup a MBA for graduate school research. I'll be doing the basics - lots of Chrome tabs and Office apps. I have been using Windows for a few years but would like something with a large screen and great battery life. I will be keeping my Windows laptop for advanced Excel and other Windows only applications.

I had my eye on the Space Grey 15" MBA for several months. I like how it looks good in an office environment. I'm not a fan of colorful or light laptops. I know this might sound ridiculous, but I'm thinking of ordering a M3 15" MBA for $100 less through a third party retailer. I don't really care about the camera upgrade and only use 2 monitors with the laptop closed at most. How big is the difference between M3 and M4? Is it stupid to buy the M3 version at a discount because I prefer the color?

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!
 
  • Like
Reactions: StoneJack
25% give or take. It depends what you're doing.

Although the NPE on the M4 is a huge step forwards, which will likely lead to Apple, at some point, saying "these Apple Intelligence features are M4 only"
 
Lots of Chrome tabs for research, Word, Excel, and Powerpoint. I saw the 25% performance jump, but I went to the Apple store yesterday and compared a M4 MBP and the existing M3 Air, and couldn't really see a difference. I just prefer the darker, plainer look of Space Grey. I know it sounds ridiculous but figured might as well get the color I want for a little cheaper if the difference won't matter to me.
 
Hi all, I need to pickup a MBA for graduate school research. I'll be doing the basics - lots of Chrome tabs and Office apps. I have been using Windows for a few years but would like something with a large screen and great battery life. I will be keeping my Windows laptop for advanced Excel and other Windows only applications.

I had my eye on the Space Grey 15" MBA for several months. I like how it looks good in an office environment. I'm not a fan of colorful or light laptops. I know this might sound ridiculous, but I'm thinking of ordering a M3 15" MBA for $100 less through a third party retailer. I don't really care about the camera upgrade and only use 2 monitors with the laptop closed at most. How big is the difference between M3 and M4? Is it stupid to buy the M3 version at a discount because I prefer the color?

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!

There’s nothing wrong with buying the M3 because it will do everything you need it to do. However, if you have any intent to keep the laptop for an extended period of time, the M4 will get updates longer.

My question is are you saying it’s $100 cheaper to buy the M3 from a third-party retailer versus buying a brand new M4? For $100 I would buy the M4. It would take at least $200 for me to consider it. Of course $100 to you may not be the same as $100 to me. If you’ve saved up for months then maybe $100 is significant.

This reminds me of a friend that bought a laptop and the only spec she based her purchase on was the laptop was pink. I guess if the other colors really bother you then it’s not going to be a huge downgrade or anything. I feel like you should get a better deal than $100 cheaper than the latest model.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drrich2 and JSRinUK
There’s nothing wrong with buying the M3 because it will do everything you need it to do. However, if you have any intent to keep the laptop for an extended period of time, the M4 will get updates longer.

My question is are you saying it’s $100 cheaper to buy the M3 from a third-party retailer versus buying a brand new M4? For $100 I would buy the M4. It would take at least $200 for me to consider it. Of course $100 to you may not be the same as $100 to me. If you’ve saved up for months then maybe $100 is significant.

This reminds me of a friend that bought a laptop and the only spec she based her purchase on was the laptop was pink. I guess if the other colors really bother you then it’s not going to be a huge downgrade or anything. I feel like you should get a better deal than $100 cheaper than the latest model.
Thanks for your feedback. There is an Apple refurb that ends up being $200 cheaper - 1099 for the 16/512. That same config on M4 would be 1299.
 
  • Like
Reactions: russell_314
Thanks for your feedback. There is an Apple refurb that ends up being $200 cheaper - 1099 for the 16/512. That same config on M4 would be 1299.
So you’re going from new current model to refurbished previous model for $200.

It bugs me how small of a price drop this is however, it’s still saving $200. If that’s a consideration, then I don’t think you’re going to be unhappy with M3. I have the M2 and while I really want to upgrade, it’s only for the stupid blue and I just can’t do it right now. I feel like that’s silly. I like the blue so much but to me that’s a waste of money.

If you like the M3 go for it. There’s not going to be some feature that requires M4. I’m sure there is some speed difference if you’re doing heavy tasks, but I would likely bet money that doing normal tasks like browsing the web there’s likely no noticeable difference. Even on things that there will be a difference like editing videos it’s not like you’re on a deadline working for Disney to get things done. most people are not going to be under such time constraints where taking an extra three minutes to render a video will cause them problems.
 
If you like the M3 go for it. There’s not going to be some feature that requires M4.
Given the difference in NPE on M3 vs M4, I fully expect that to become a differentiator for Apple Intelligence features at some point.
 
Hi all, I need to pickup a MBA for graduate school research. I'll be doing the basics - lots of Chrome tabs and Office apps. I have been using Windows for a few years but would like something with a large screen and great battery life. I will be keeping my Windows laptop for advanced Excel and other Windows only applications.

I had my eye on the Space Grey 15" MBA for several months. I like how it looks good in an office environment. I'm not a fan of colorful or light laptops. I know this might sound ridiculous, but I'm thinking of ordering a M3 15" MBA for $100 less through a third party retailer. I don't really care about the camera upgrade and only use 2 monitors with the laptop closed at most. How big is the difference between M3 and M4? Is it stupid to buy the M3 version at a discount because I prefer the color?

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!
main difference is in video encoding and image processing speed. Other than that, M3 and M4 are pretty identical in everything. you are not going to open 25% more Chrome tabs because you use M4 - M3 will handle all those academic tasks easily. So save some money and after few years you can invest into M6 or whatever is latest.
 
While the M4 is a pretty big jump in processing power from the M3, its nothing you will notice unless you are doing work that requires high performance. Go with what you like. : )
 
I have various questions, but to start with, could someone advise which ports I should use on the monitor and the MacMini
You might consider adding a 'shell' or skin if the color disagrees with you. I bought a shell for my old 2017 12" MacBook - https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07GH49C7B?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_10 (no longer available, but you can see what it was).

There are also skin options, like these vinyl (IIRC) skins from Mighty Skins.

My point it, you can make it look how you want, you're not stuck with looking at the original color, and some options may offer some limited protection (e.g.: from scratches; don't plan on dropping it).
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
You are a graduate student. So this might be the last personal computer you buy for a while depending on a lot of variables but possibly this is the case.

You are going to want something to last as long as possible both in terms of software support and in terms of speed, processing power. I would say you should get a 14" M4 MBP but if 15" air is better suited for your needs I would certainly recommend a grad student spend the extra $100 for the latest processor.

If you had your life set up, good job, home or condo or apartment, car, etc then buying certain things on a sort of regular basis depending on what life throws at you. As someone still in school none of these variables have been set up yet so I would assume that you want the best device you can get for a while since you may not be able to upgrade for while. If the cost is similar then I would go for the M4 MBP 14" just because the screen sizes are all so similar and in a students case again having the best specs all around that one can afford are very important and I would cheap out. You will be thanking me for many years if you just spend a little extra as long as you use it as intended then the extra money will pay for itself later on.

I have an air and love it so don't get me wrong. I am not saying don't buy and air. Just make sure $100 again is not making a choice vs. the Pro has 120hz pro motion, better color accuracy, better speakers, a fan if needed, more ports, etc vs the air is much more portable anti has better colors, and it has NO fans. People really don't understand how Nice it is not to hear ANY fans on my laptop no matter what I do. I will use a Windows laptop I have and as soon as I boot up until I shut it down fans are running. Sometimes I am doing practically nothing on the Windows laptops and the fans are just blasting and this is on a newer Intel Ultra processor vs my air that is cool and no fans??

So I am not saying to buy this or buy that. You decide what is best for you and in your budget and I have been worried about spending so much money and wanted to cut a corner here or there so it would be more affordable and regretted it later. Better to spend a little more on M4 than m3 or a little more on M4 14" MBP vs 15" air if that is what you prefer or buying the right m4 MBA with enough ram and storage within a budget. I think ram is most important consideration since external drives are cheap and plentiful or cloud storage for college. I mean if any situation was perfect for cloud storage University is perfect. Good luck whatever you decide. I am sure you can't go wrong either way!
 
Hi all, I need to pickup a MBA for graduate school research. I'll be doing the basics - lots of Chrome tabs and Office apps. I have been using Windows for a few years but would like something with a large screen and great battery life. I will be keeping my Windows laptop for advanced Excel and other Windows only applications.

I had my eye on the Space Grey 15" MBA for several months. I like how it looks good in an office environment. I'm not a fan of colorful or light laptops. I know this might sound ridiculous, but I'm thinking of ordering a M3 15" MBA for $100 less through a third party retailer. I don't really care about the camera upgrade and only use 2 monitors with the laptop closed at most. How big is the difference between M3 and M4? Is it stupid to buy the M3 version at a discount because I prefer the color?

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!
Hello Jarousin,

I cannot comment on the M3 performance, since I don't have one. I can talk about my experience with a 15" Air M4 32/1T midnight. I also can tell you that my previous machine was a 16" M1 Pro 16/1T in space gray.

I liked the Pro in almost every aspect, I never heard the fans, but size and weight was always an issue. I considered the 14" pro but for me it is too small to work effectively without an external screen all the time. I am also a student, but also a teacher so my use case can be similar to yours.
I understand the color dilema, a computer we like to look at and use is more productive. I like black colors on devices, although my 15 pro is white because of a good deal, but I use a black case and the front is black anyway. My biggest concern was about fingerprints, honestly they are somehow visible, but not much.
The experience has been so far fantastic. The processor temperatures are similar to M1 Pro, typically less than 40ºC, and even on the lap the computer is very comfortable. With the Pro it was not as pleasant mainly because of the weight. Here are some photos comparing a M1 2020 Air (previous version without the notch), the Air and the Pro.
I find the M4 faster than the M1 Pro that I had, and cannot really see, unless side by side, the difference in display quality (I don't have HDR content). Side by side there are differences in the blacks, but the 120Hz promotion is, to me, a gimmick. For working in documents, coding, browsing and mail I cannot see a manifest difference.

The battery life is just mind blowing. Writing, coding, browsing, mail, Wi-Fi on and BT the computer draws around 4w. I use aldente and limit battery charge to 85% with 7% sailing. I placed a matte screen protector that was satisfactory for some days, then it started showing dust so I removed it. I never saw a nano display in person to compare, but those are just available on the pro, which I think is adequate for the user target. The Air could benefit from it, but I doubt many people would buy it anyway, it is more expensive and from what I saw on images and videos the image is not as sharp (as well as with the screen protector I was using).

The. sound is amazing on the Pro. But in my use case I used it maybe 4/5 times in more than 2 years of ownership, and of those 2 were to show my colleagues 😂. I prefer earphones/headphones. But if you use the computer sound for music and to be engaged the Air 15 is clearly inferior in this aspect. Not so in terms of maximum volume, but more on bass. It is just not in the same league.

Next ports. Yes, it would be better to have ports on opposite sides of the computer, but only the headphone jack is present on the right side. I believe it has always been like that on the Airs, it makes the construction easier I guess. Since it has magsafe at least there are two fully available ports. Would I trade the magsafe for a third port? Yes. Even more if that port was on the other side.
I don't miss HDMI or SD card slot. I am not a graphics/photographer worker. For an external display I have a 30e USB-C hub that connects one port to HDMI, Ethernet, Power and extra USB ports. On some occasions I use a portable monitor (16" 2,5k from AZORPA) that makes it even better since I don't have to power the display.

As for the M3 vs M4. I would not consider the software support time as a differentiator. M1 is 5 years old and it will still have support for more 2 or 3 at least. I believe even more, I would expect around 10 years since launch. Surely it will show its limitations in AI support and some features will lag or start to be unavailable. Not an issue for M3.
The differentiator is real dual monitor support, better GPU, more CPU cores and faster memory interface, energy efficiency due to optimized node, 2x faster neural engine.
Will that make me spend 200USD/euro more in the same configuration? Yes, that is around 10% on a 32/1T version and it would be difficult to find a 24G version of M3 here, most are 16G and 512GB SSD at most.
Mine costed 2374e with education discount. For comparison a 14 Pro with same configuration would cost me 2554e. The nano display would cost more 171e, reaching 2725.

Feel free to ask me anything about the machine, I'll try to help.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3994.jpeg
    IMG_3994.jpeg
    278.8 KB · Views: 34
  • IMG_3992.jpeg
    IMG_3992.jpeg
    332.5 KB · Views: 27
  • IMG_3990.jpeg
    IMG_3990.jpeg
    299.3 KB · Views: 28
Last edited:
While the M4 is a pretty big jump in processing power from the M3, its nothing you will notice unless you are doing work that requires high performance. Go with what you like. : )
The processing speed difference is probably the one thing that's least different between the two. The M4 is like 25% faster, but it's also clocked 25% faster and uses 25% more power. In other words, it's an overclocked m3.

The GPU and NPU, and codec differences are the largest changes between generations, IMO.
 
The processing speed difference is probably the one thing that's least different between the two. The M4 is like 25% faster, but it's also clocked 25% faster and uses 25% more power. In other words, it's an overclocked m3.

This just isn’t true. It’s about 25% faster but uses about 10% more power and about 10% more clock speed. There are architectural differences between the M3 and M4. It has more transistors and is manufactured on a different node.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Macbookey
I know 16" MBP is a lot heavier, but if you want a bigger and better screen and don't mind the weight, even a refurb 16" offers so-much-more.

On your original question, doing a side-by-side now with an 13" M4 16/256 and M3 24/512 (both within $100 of each other new).

Impressions:
  • M4 is surprisingly snappier than M3. Didn't think this would be noticeable, but it is. Geekbench on both computers showed a shocking 25% advantage M4 on single core performance.
  • M3 not "slow" by any stretch. It's perfectly fine.
  • Screen/speaker differences negligible (i.e. average).
  • Surprisingly, M4 keyboard "feels" more solid than M3. Could be manufacturer variation, but M3 keys protrude more from the chassis and have more "wobble."
Hope this helps. Overall, though, if I could stretch to the same specs on an M4 I would do it.
 
This just isn’t true. It’s about 25% faster but uses about 10% more power and about 10% more clock speed. There are architectural differences between the M3 and M4. It has more transistors and is manufactured on a different node.
You may be right. I can't find the graph. Maybe it was battery life vs a CPU+GPU test? The end result was that the jump in test score as a percent almost perfectly matched the CPU increase as a percent, and had a negative correlation to battery life or power usage as a percent that mirrored the increase in score.
 
I know 16" MBP is a lot heavier, but if you want a bigger and better screen and don't mind the weight, even a refurb 16" offers so-much-more.

On your original question, doing a side-by-side now with an 13" M4 16/256 and M3 24/512 (both within $100 of each other new).

Impressions:
  • M4 is surprisingly snappier than M3. Didn't think this would be noticeable, but it is. Geekbench on both computers showed a shocking 25% advantage M4 on single core performance.
  • M3 not "slow" by any stretch. It's perfectly fine.
  • Screen/speaker differences negligible (i.e. average).
  • Surprisingly, M4 keyboard "feels" more solid than M3. Could be manufacturer variation, but M3 keys protrude more from the chassis and have more "wobble."
Hope this helps. Overall, though, if I could stretch to the same specs on an M4 I would do it.
I fully understand your "so-much-more" expression. It is true if one needs it, if not one is just carrying extra weight and size for the sake of better screen, speakers and thermal headroom that one may seldom benefit from.
So the point is use case and requirements. As I mentioned I came form a 16 M1 Pro that I really liked but never pushed it to see where it shines. As it stand out it was just more weight and size, that ultimately prevented me from using the machine in the couch.

Decisions, decisions 😉
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.