M4 MBA: Did the Key-Plastic get better?

[handbagapple]

Hey guys,

I've noticed that the key plastic seems much more durable this time. Maybe it's just me, or perhaps they've actually improved the quality. What are your thoughts?

Recently, I had an M4 MacBook Pro, used it for just one day before realizing I'd prefer the 15-inch screen at kindof the same weigth and didn't need that much power, so I returned it (the M4 MacBook Air release was imminent at this point). However, I could already see a noticeable difference between the keys I frequently used and those I barely touched (like the function row), simply based on shininess/ wear off of the Plastic. After just a day, it looked a bit like my Magic Keyboard from the M1 iPad Pro after three years of usage... The MBA Keys still are looking as good as new to me.

 

[smirking]

I've noticed that the key plastic seems much more durable this time. Maybe it's just me, or perhaps they've actually improved the quality. What are your thoughts?

I don't know if I'd equate keys that don't get as shiny as being more durable.

I have noticed that the keys on my new 14" M4 MBP still look almost new after 3 months of ownership... and I'm not a fan. I'd much rather have the old shiny keycaps from my old M1 Pro.

Why? There seems to be a different coating on my M4 keycaps. I don't think it means they're more durable... just less shiny. The consequence of that coating is that the keys feel slippery and I find it more difficult to type on them.

Don't get me wrong. I hate having a greasy looking keyboard, but if I can only choose one, I'll always choose performance over aesthetics.

 

[gnyce]

the keys do feel and look a bit better but I can't say that its just in my head or not. (from m2 to m4)