I think it might have more to do with the wifi card being a different device on the new machine, but is it possible to still get those off of my old Mac?
Talked to AppleCare, and we figured out that even though they seemed non-existant on my new machine since my Keychain was migrated, the keys actually were transferred over within the Keychain.
So, you can copy and paste them from Keychain Access and readd the networks.