Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

amassoodapple

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Apr 3, 2011
2
0
Hello everyone, i just wanted to ask everyones opinion on something that i have been thinking about for a very long time. Right now i have a 2008 Mac pro 8 core w/ 8gb ram/ 2tb hd/ nvidia geforce 8800gt. I use my mac pro for normal use but also final cut studio using 1080p video editing.

I also have a MBP 15 inch i think 2007 or 8. It has 2.4ghz dual core w/ 4gb ram. The screen on it is currently broken and i haven't gotten around to replacing it yet because im not sure if it is worth it. I also used my laptop for final cut editing on the go.

With the release of the 2011 MBP and their amazing specs, im wondering if i should sell my current MP and MBP and get the 17' or 15' quad core mac book pros with the 750gb hdd and 1gb vram.

My question is-- IS IT WORTH IT??
Obviously it won't preform as well as my current 2008 mac pro but can it get close. A little less speed is fine but it cant take like 15 minutes more to render something. Thats what im concerned about.

Or should i just stick with my mac pro and get the screen on my MBP fixed? One thing i like about the MBP is portability obviously.
 
Well, a good question is do you need to be portable all the time? For myself I find a desktop and a laptop and good thing.

A desktop you can easily upgrade and add things (RAM, HD, etc), while a laptop is a bit more difficult. Plus, if your laptop/desktop has to go in for repairs, then you have something to fall back on.

IMHO, if the MBP has a broken screen, maybe you can find a screen on ebay, or may just sell it for parts. Granted you may not get a lot for it, but then you can save and get another MBP.

In the end, its really your choice....
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.