Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
67,468
37,713


From Apple's Mac lineup, the company sells many more laptops than desktop computers, part of a trend that has been in place for years. Apple's laptops are well made, they offer more than enough performance for a majority of users, and you can take the laptop with you wherever you go.

Apple's laptop lineup consists of two models: the MacBook Pro and the MacBook Air. There are some obvious and nuanced differences between the two models that you need to consider while shopping for a Mac laptop. In this guide, we'll take a look at the specifics, the differences, and the performance of the MacBook Pro and MacBook Air to help you decide which laptop is best for you.

Why you should pick a MacBook Pro

Of the two laptop lineups, the MacBook Pro is the one outfitted with a Retina display. These displays have many more pixels than the MacBook Air displays, which means images and text will look very sharp and clean -- it's a pleasing aesthetic if you're spending all day at the computer. The high resolution is also great for anyone who's working in HD video, allowing you to work in actual size and still have room for your app's interface.

Apple's definition of "Retina" is when a user, at a typical usage distance, cannot see the individual pixels on the screen. The 13-inch Retina MacBook Pro has a resolution of 2560 x 1600, while the 15-inch Retina MacBook Pro has a resolution of 2880 x 1800. In comparison, the non-Retina MacBook Air has a 1366 x 768 (11-inch) or 1440 x 900 (13-inch) resolution, so you can see there's quite a difference between the displays of Apple's two notebook lines.

macbook_pro_13_15_late_2013.jpg

The MacBook Pro is positioned as a computer than's just as good performance-wise as a desktop computer. In general, the MacBook Pro is quite a bit faster than the MacBook Air, with the stock 13-inch models offering 2.6GHz to 2.8GHz dual-core processors and the stock 15-inch models offering 2.2GHz to 2.5GHz quad-core processors. Apps that take advantage of multiple cores, like Final Cut Pro, Photoshop, Logic Pro X, and more, are especially well suited to the 15-inch Retina MacBook Pro.

You're going to want to choose a Retina MacBook Pro if you're big on gaming. The MacBook Pros have superior GPUs, and the top-of-the-line $2,499 15-inch version even has a dedicated Nvidia GeForce GT 750M graphics card along with integrated Iris Pro graphics like the rest of the MacBook Pro lineup. It'll switch between the two cards to maximize performance and battery life.

macbookpro-macbookair-geekbench-multi-mid2014-800x499.jpg

All of Apple's newest MacBooks have amazing battery life. The 13-inch Retina MacBook Pro offers 9 hours of web browsing or iTunes playback, while the 15-inch model offers 8 hours of web browsing/iTunes playback. One thing to keep in mind though, the less powerful MacBook Air has the best battery life out of any of Apple's notebooks -- the 13-inch version lasts for up to 12 hours when browsing the web or when playing a video.

On the downside, the MacBook Pro is quite a bit heavier than the MacBook Air. Both the 13 and 15-inch models are under five pounds, with the former weighing in at 3.46 pounds and the latter at 4.46 pounds. That might not sound like a lot, but after an hour or two of schlepping a MacBook Pro around, 3 to 5 pounds can feel like 20.

You're basically picking processing power and display over superior portability when you choose a Retina MacBook Pro, and you're sacrificing a little bit of battery life. MacBook Pros are also the more expensive of the two notebook lines, with the entry-level 13-inch model priced at $1,299 and the entry-level 15-inch model priced at $1,999 -- these are considered desktop replacements, after all.

Learn about the specifications of the MacBook Pro.

Why you should pick a MacBook Air

Travel is the forte of the MacBook Air. It's lightweight (under three pounds) and won't take up a lot of space in a bag. The smaller size comes with compromises, such as smaller non-Retina screens and slower performance, but if you're using your laptop in meetings, a classroom, or a coffee shop for relatively simple tasks, those compromises may not matter too much.

macbook_air_2014.jpg

Apple's most affordable laptops are MacBook Airs with prices that start at $899, but that's not to say that the MacBook Air offers entry-level performance -- these are machines that can handle all of your day to day tasks. If your workload consists mostly of productivity tasks that use single-core apps (web, email, word processors, spreadsheets, presentations, etc.) and you're frequently on-the-go, you'll be happy with the performance of the MacBook Air. There's nothing stopping you from using a pro-level app, but the 1.4GHz dual-core processor limits the performance.

If you're a heavy user of apps that are really designed more for multi-core machines, like Final Cut Pro, Photoshop, or Logic Pro X, you may not be satisfied with the performance that a MacBook Air offers.

macbookpro-macbookair-geekbench-single-mid2014-800x380.jpg

There's a reason that the MacBook Air is one of Apple's most popular offerings -- they're amazingly portable. The 11-inch model weighs just 2.38 pounds while the 13-inch model weighs 2.96, and both models are just 0.68 inches thick. Battery life is another major draw. The 11-inch model will last for nine hours when browsing the web or watching videos, and the 13-inch model will last for a whopping 12 hours during the same tasks. That's enough battery life to more than make it through a full work day.

If you already read through the MacBook Pro section of this guide, you know the major trade off when choosing a MacBook Air -- you're losing out on that gorgeous Retina screen. You're also missing out on faster performance, but if you need a machine for travel purposes, you won't go wrong with a MacBook Air.

Get more information about the MacBook Air specifications.

Why you might want to wait

You've done your research, you've got your credit card out, and you're ready to buy -- but you might want to wait, especially if you want to buy a MacBook Air.

The current MacBook Air was released in April of 2014, so there's a real possibility a new MacBook Air could come out soon. Recently, Intel announced its new Broadwell processors, which could be used in a new MacBook Air. Not only are the processors new, but they also feature improved integrated graphics. According to a report by AnandTech, the first computers using the new 15-watt Broadwell-U chips -- the ones that could be used in a MacBook Air -- are expected at the end of January.

broadwell_u.jpg

A little more sensational is the rumor of a 12-inch MacBook Air, which could have a Retina display. The 12-inch MacBook Air will feature a complete redesign that introduces an ultra slim body that might do away with several existing ports, including the MagSafe, relying instead on a USB Type-C connector for charging and peripherals. It's also rumored to have slimmer display bezels and an edge-to-edge keyboard design. It's not clear exactly when the 12-inch MacBook Air might launch, but current rumors suggest it's already in production for a spring to early summer launch.

15607725144_ef44411b5b_b-800x601.jpg
Rendering of the 12-inch MacBook by Martin Hajek

As for the MacBook Pro, the current version was released in July of 2014 and it looks like Broadwell Retina MacBook Pro machines may not be ready for a few months yet. The 28-watt Broadwell-U processors with the new Iris 6100 integrated graphics appropriate for the 13-inch Retina MacBook Pro are available, but chips appropriate for the 15-inch MacBook Pro will not be released in quantity until July or August, making an update before that time unlikely.

Of course, if you need a new laptop now, then buy one. If you have a Core 2 Duo-based MacBook, you'll benefit greatly from the current offerings. If your laptop is two or three years old, you should probably wait, since you'll see a better price/performance improvement with the new Broadwell-based MacBooks.

Which Mac laptop should you buy?

So you want to buy a MacBook Pro for its performance and Retina display. Which one should you get? The $1,499 13-inch MacBook Pro hits a sweet spot, offering more storage capacity (256GB) than the $1,299 model. And it's only a few percentage points slower than the $1,799 model, which is your only option if you want a 13-inch MacBook Pro with 512GB of storage.

If you prefer a 15-inch laptop, you should get the $2,499 MacBook Pro if you use a lot of pro apps -- you'll benefit from the 512GB of storage and the discrete Nvidia graphics subsystem.

The MacBook Air is great for users who need a computer for productivity tasks while traveling. If you can afford it, opt for a model with 256GB of flash storage -- not only do you get more room to store files, but you also get a slight speed boost as the 256GB model is a bit faster, according to speed tests. Remember, you don't get as many ports as you would on a MacBook Pro, so make sure you have the proper adapters.

Apple also makes a $1,099 non-Retina MacBook Pro that we didn't mention in this guide, but that's not really worth purchasing unless you desperately need dedicated FireWire, Ethernet and/or a SuperDrive. The non-Retina MacBook is old, slow, and will probably be discontinued in the near future.

Article Link: MacBook Air vs. MacBook Pro: Which Apple Notebook to Choose
 
Last edited:
The benchmark chart doesn't feature the i7 macbook air, whereabouts would that come?
 
What about

People who want MBA power but 15" of screen, regular or retina, doesn't matter?

Like, you know, me.

15" screen, 512 SSD hard drive, max available RAM so it can last for years.

It's a terrible place to be.
 
Buy neither, wait for the 12" Retina Air :D (that's what I'm doing)

If Apples finally decides to finally introduce a redesigned Air I'm all in even though my nearly 5 years old Air still runs pretty impressive with Yosemite :D

Btw: Still not sure if the rumored 12" will actually replace the 13"?
 
Only reason I feel the need to go Pro is that I can't get an Air with a 15-inch panel. 13 just gets too small for my taste. Else I'd be fine with a worse performing computer, having an iMac for Final Cut.
 
Give the Air a little more credit

I have a top spec 13" 2014 Air (i7, 8GB RAM, 512GB SSD). I use it for both work and personal use. I work as a Software Engineer, mostly developing Java in Eclipse (which is a pig). With the various applications I need running for development, it really should be slow, but I never notice any slowdown. I'm not sure how much faster the i7 is than the i5, but the i7 Air has always been very fast for me. Before I upgraded I had a 15" 2011 Pro, the Air is much faster than that was.

I think the biggest downside is probably the graphics card, but that doesn't matter for video playback. 3D rendering is slow, and when I use Exposé, especially on my Thunderbolt display, I can feel the GPU struggling.

When AppleCare runs out on the Air, I probably will get the 13" Pro. It's only about $200 more, and a little larger/heavier, but the extra expandability in terms of RAM and Thunderbolt ports would be nice.

EDIT: Forgot to mention the display. The Pro has Retina, which looks beautiful, but gives you the equivalent screen real estate of a 1280x800 display (for 13" Pro models), whereas the Air has a 1440x900 display (again, for the 13" Air). However, you can actually turn retina "off", thus giving you a 2560x1600 screen, and I believe you can even choose other scaling levels.
 
Last edited:
On the downside, the MacBook Pro is quite a bit heavier than the MacBook Air. Both the 13 and 15-inch models are under five pounds, with the latter weighing in at 3.46 pounds and the former at 4.46 pounds. That might not sound like a lot, but after an hour or two of schlepping a MacBook Pro around, 3 to 5 pounds can feel like 20.

The former (13") is 3.46 lbs, the latter (15") is 4.46 lbs. https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs-retina/
 
Both the 13 and 15-inch models are under five pounds, with the former weighing in at 3.46 pounds and the latter at 4.46 pounds. That might not sound like a lot, but after an hour or two of schlepping a MacBook Pro around, 3 to 5 pounds can feel like 20.

schlep
/SHlep/
North American, informal

verb
gerund or present participle: schlepping

haul or carry (something heavy or awkward)
"she schlepped her groceries home"
 
I choose neither. To me apple laptops are lacking the value they used to have, Give me a nice mac desktop and an iPad Air 2 and I'm good to go! ## just my opinion
 
They should converge. Why choose between big and powerful or thin and dinky.

The MBP is big?? The MBA is dinky?? I think many would disagree with both.

However, it's pretty clear that Apple wants to keep the distinction. That's the direction they will be going with the new 12" MBA. Super thin, light, portable, etc MBA vs the powerful "Pro" MBP.
 
tl;dr: buy the MBP15 if you have big pockets, don't buy either of the 13-inchs

Don't buy the Air because non-Retina displays are clearly being phased out and there's a possible design refresh incoming. And when that design refresh appears, don't buy that either (at first) because 1st Gen Apple devices have always had problems.

Don't buy the 13-inch Pro because the internals are still significantly underpowered for that display, especially the GPU. Very significant processor/GPU upgrades from Intel should be here in 6-8 months.
 
The 2012 Macbook Pro Non-Retina deserves more credit then it gets. It benchmarks above the Macbook Air, and if you install an SSD, it flys.
 
I'm still disappointed by Apple's decision to go with non-user-replaceable RAM in the MBPs.

If the trend is toward soldering on account of quality control and thinness, then fine — there's also less waste generated when you pay for max RAM upfront than when you replace the original with aftermarket sticks. But for the sake of power and longevity, Apple should at least have the option to max out the RAM instead of artificially limiting it. The current MBPs only come with up to 16GB, but they support up to 32GB. That's a significant difference.
 
Because I will do Photoshop work few times I need to go the Pro route.

I would love to get an Air due the portability and the small footprint but when it comes to have power for hungry apps like Photoshop, unfortunately the Air is not the best option due small RAM, processor and storage sizes.
Sure I can upgrade these but then the prices get very close to the Pro, so better go the Pro route for the money.

----------

I'm still disappointed by Apple's decision to go with non-user-replaceable RAM in the MBPs.

If the trend is toward soldering on account of quality control and thinness, then fine — there's also less waste generated when you pay for max RAM upfront than when you replace the original with aftermarket sticks. But for the sake of power and longevity, Apple should at least have the option to max out the RAM instead of artificially limiting it. The current MBPs only come with up to 16GB, but they support up to 32GB. That's a significant difference.

This would be a non issue if Apple would charge more reasonable prices on RAM.
But again we don't have much choice. If you need RAM better max it upfront.
 
Last edited:
I choose neither. To me apple laptops are lacking the value they used to have, Give me a nice mac desktop and an iPad Air 2 and I'm good to go! ## just my opinion

While I am an iMac and iPad combo user I don't know about lacking in value. Having a desktop Mac is not a realistic option for some folks.
 
13 rMBP vs 13 MBA:

0.5 lb heavier
Similar thickness
Similar battery life
$300 more

But you get roughly:

2X CPU speed
2X RAM
2X SSD
2X Resolution
More ports

Winner: 13 rMBP
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.