i don't have the exact model you mentioned but i do have a Maxtor one touch 200GB Firewire 800 edition and i am loving it so far. and it's not because of the "one touch" feature at all, which is just a bundled version of Dantz Retrospect. the keyword here being "Retro" as that software is really showing its age and the interface is the absolute worst. so i use Backup 3 instead. anyway, the reason i DO like the drive is because it has a Maxtor HD inside, which i've always had good luck with in desktops etc. Lacie, on the other hand, uses Western Digital inside which IMHO are the worst drives in existence. i say this because just about every WD drive i have ever owned has crapped out on me, in some cases taking many GBs of important data along with it. ironically, that need of a backup solution is what made me purchase a Lacie FW drive to begin with. it lasted just over 6 months before it one day just ate the dust. it was sort of an emergency so i pryed it open to remove the drive and sure enough, Western Digital inside. i will never buy Lacie or Western Digital again. i'm Maxtor and Seagate all the way these days.